Billionaire PayPal founder Peter Thiel loses bid to build $10m home in New Zealand
Billionaire PayPal co-founder Peter Thiel has lost his bid to build a multi-million dollar ‘eco-lodge’ in a New Zealand beauty spot after coucillors ruled it would have too-great an impact on the environment.
Thiel, who is worth an estimated $7.7billion, had been applying to build a sprawling lodge containing a spa, ‘meditation pod’ and library overlooking Lake Wanaka on New Zealand’s pristine South Island.
But Queenstown-Lakes district council on Thursday turned down the application following outcry from environmentalists who said it would ‘destroy our beautiful lake environment’.
In their ruling, councillors said the home would ‘be of a sufficiently large scale and impact that it will draw the eye and be inappropriately dominant.’ In doing so, they rejected arguments put forward by Thiel’s lawyers that objections were put forward on the basis of ‘environmental protection at all costs’.
Thiel – an outspoken libertarian and ex-Trump supporter – is thought to already own property in New Zealand, a country he was attracted to because he believes it would be the safest location to out-last a major global catastrophe, according to friend and fellow billionaire Sam Altman.
Mr Thiel is facing a backlash from New Zealand eco-groups over plans for a sprawling luxury lodge built into the hills overlooking South Island’s Lake Wanaka, complete with a spa, meditation ‘pod’ and library
But the eccentric billionaire is facing anger from eco-groups who claim his lodge would ‘destroy our beautiful lake environment’ and ‘likely to cause significant adverse physical changes to the appearance of the natural landscape when viewed from public places in the vicinity’
In total, the council received seven formal submissions opposing or asking for changes to the plan, and none in support
In a six-page letter to Queenstown Lakes District Council, the Upper Clutha Environmental Society said it opposed the application in its entirety and claimed the buildings would be an eyesore on the natural landscape
The Society argued Mr Thiel ‘has not meaningfully avoided, remedied or mitigated adverse effects’, calling the proposals ‘inappropriate’ and adding that the development is ‘extremely unlikely’ to meet the ‘reasonably difficult to see test’ set by the local council
Mr Thiel, who was granted New Zealand citizenship ten years ago in controversial circumstances after being in the country for just 12 days, wants to build the lodge and a private residential building on the $10million, 477-acre estate that he owns near Queenstown
Billionaire PayPal founder Peter Thiel
Plans for a ‘meditation pod’ at the house had been scrapped during the application process to try and appease campaigners, but when inspectors visited the site they were troubled by how large the home would be and how visible it would be from different points around the lake.
Embedded into the landscape, creating the property would have involved works spanning a total of 18 acres, according to The Guardian.
In a six-page letter to Queenstown Lakes District Council, the Upper Clutha Environmental Society said it opposed the application in its entirety and claimed the buildings would be an eyesore on the natural landscape.
The Society argued Mr Thiel ‘has not meaningfully avoided, remedied or mitigated adverse effects’, calling the proposals ‘inappropriate’ and adding that the development is ‘extremely unlikely’ to meet the ‘reasonably difficult to see test’ set by the local council.
Longview Environmental Trust argued the location was inappropriate and would be highly visible. And local resident John Sutton said in a submission to council that the lodge would ‘destroy our beautiful lake environment’, The Guardian reported.
In total, the council received seven formal submissions opposing or asking for changes to the plan, and none in support.
In a consent application for the lodge on his property, Second Star Ltd – a company owned by the entrepreneur – said the development would include a ‘pod’, water features and meditation space.
The proposal argues that the architects ‘have designed the proposal to blend the buildings in to the undulating landscape that surrounds them’, adding: ‘All of the buildings include green roofs which extend to the ground of each end of the buildings.
‘The green roofs are to be planted with the same range of plants (and occasional rocks) that occur on the surrounding hillock landforms’.
It also describes ‘a series of stand-alone buildings, including a lodge for visitor accommodation for up to 24 guests, accommodation pod for the owner, together with associated lodge management buildings, infrastructure, landscape treatment, water features and meditation space’.
The earthworks required to build it would cover over 73,700 sq m of land.
Details of the development, designed by Tokyo Olympic Stadium architect Kengo Kuma and Associates, emerged in a planning application in August.
They show several buildings that are designed to blend into the landscape, a private home built into a hillside as well as a larger luxury lodge with enough space for 24 people.
In a consent application for the lodge on his property, Second Star Ltd – a company owned by the entrepreneur – said the development would include a ‘pod’, water features and meditation space
The proposal argues that the architects ‘have designed the proposal to blend the buildings in to the undulating landscape that surrounds them’, adding: ‘All of the buildings include green roofs which extend to the ground of each end of the buildings’
It also describes ‘a series of stand-alone buildings, including a lodge for visitor accommodation for up to 24 guests, accommodation pod for the owner, together with associated lodge management buildings, infrastructure, landscape treatment, water features and meditation space’
The earthworks required to build it would cover over 73,700 sq m of land
The application states: ‘The applicants seek to develop a lodge for visitor accommodation purposes, which comprises three individual structures but constructed as one building, which are described in the landscape assessment as a series of pods.
‘The Owner’s Pod, back of house and a meditation pod will also be constructed. All buildings will be constructed near the building platform identified on the title.
‘The lodge is designed in a manner that integrates the building forms into the context of the landscape and the site whilst providing each guest room with uninterrupted north-facing views towards Lake Wanaka and the Southern Alps.
‘The lodge location provides the benefits of relative proximity to Wanaka and the shopping, dining and cultural experiences that are available, whilst also providing guests with a sense of remoteness.
‘The lodge can accommodate up to 24 guests (two per bedroom) and an additional six people in the Owner’s Pod. Up to 15 staff will attend the site at peak times, none of whom will reside on site. An informal walking track is proposed (compacted hardfill subbase with an amenity gravel applied to the top surface) around parts of the property as shown on the Landscape Plans, with specifically located viewpoints where guests can admire the view.
‘The meditation space is proposed as a quiet space away from other buildings, to allow guests to reflect, meditate and take some time out.’
Details of the development, designed by Tokyo Olympic Stadium architect Kengo Kuma and Associates, emerged in a planning application in August
In a six-page letter to Queenstown Lakes District Council, the Upper Clutha Environmental Society said it opposed the application in its entirety and claimed the buildings would be an eyesore on the natural landscape
They show several buildings that are designed to blend into the landscape, a private home built into a hillside as well as a larger luxury lodge with enough space for 24 people
The entrepreneur first visited New Zealand in 1995 when he was 28, according to an in-depth investigation by The New Zealand Herald – and is also a big fan of The Lord of the Rings movie trilogy, which was filmed in New Zealand
In 2017, it emerged that Mr Thiel was granted citizenship by the New Zealand government. Normally, the route to citizenship requires applicants to be in New Zealand as a permanent resident for at least 1,350 days in the five years preceding an application.
However, the government waived the requirement for Mr Thiel on the basis of his entrepreneurial and philanthropic activities.
The entrepreneur first visited New Zealand in 1995 when he was 28, according to an in-depth investigation by The New Zealand Herald – and is also a big fan of The Lord of the Rings movie trilogy, which was filmed in New Zealand.
New Zealand is seen by Silicon Valley tycoons as a destination to avoid government influence, and has become a popular destination with the super rich in recent years.
One of Mr Thiel’s PayPal co-founders Reid Hoffman, who later went on to create LinkedIn, told the New Yorker said New Zealand was seen as insurance for the collapse of the United States.
‘Saying you’re ”buying a house in New Zealand” is kind of a ”wink, wink, say no more”,’ Mr Hoffman said.
Mr Thiel invested in New Zealand accounting software company Xero, and its chief executive Rod Drury said American billionaires ‘treat New Zealand as a bit of a bolthole’.
Mr Thiel told Business Insider in 2011 he had found ‘utopia’ in New Zealand, and met with senior ministers including Prime Minister John Key and Finance Minister Bill English.
Authorities defended their decision to grant Mr Thiel citizenship saying he had been a great ambassador and salesperson for the country.
Billionaire Google co-founder Larry Page was granted residency in New Zealand at the start of the year.
