Elizabeth line chaos ‘sparked by supervisor stepping in to drive prepare’
A prepare driver whose service hit overhead wires that resulted in final evening’s Elizabeth line chaos was a supervisor drafted in due to a strike, a union claimed right this moment as disruption was set to proceed till at the least 7pm tonight – 24 hours after the incident.
Great Western Railway (GWR) paid the operations investigations supervisor £500 for a brief driving shift to maintain companies operating, in response to prepare drivers’ union Aslef.
The extreme disruption got here yesterday on a day that drivers for GWR have been on strike, leading to a diminished service working between 7am and 7pm on restricted routes.
Aslef additionally launched {a photograph} to MailOnline exhibiting the overhead energy cables that got here down onto the GWR prepare in West London with passengers nonetheless on board.
But GWR insisted the driving force was ‘absolutely certified with competence updated’ and that there was ‘completely no proof’ the overhead cable fault was as a result of a prepare.
The knock-on impact of the incident was that 1000’s of passengers together with James Blunt and Rachel Riley have been caught on packed rush hour trains with out energy.
seven trains have been stranded, operated by GWR, the Elizabeth line and Heathrow Express. Elizabeth line trains haven’t any bogs, including to the discomfort on board.
Delays and cancellations on the Elizabeth line, GWR and Heathrow Express – the place drivers have been additionally on strike yesterday – continued by into this afternoon.
National Rail mentioned main disruption was anticipated till at the least 7pm tonight, which means the night rush hour as folks head dwelling for the weekend can even be impacted.
![Aslef released a photo to MailOnline today showing the overhead power cables that came down onto the Great Western Railway train in West London with passengers still on board](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/12/78734919-12841573-image-m-35_1702038060919.jpg)
Aslef launched a photograph to MailOnline right this moment exhibiting the overhead energy cables that got here down onto the Great Western Railway prepare in West London with passengers nonetheless on board
![Passengers walk along the tracks after being let off the Elizabeth line train yesterday evening](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727713-12841573-Passengers_walk_along_the_tracks_after_being_let_off_the_Elizabe-a-1_1702044029016.jpg)
Passengers stroll alongside the tracks after being let off the Elizabeth line prepare yesterday night
![People climb down onto the tracks near Paddington after being stranded on a train last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78717913-12841573-People_climb_down_onto_the_tracks_near_Paddington_after_being_st-a-125_1702046114745.jpg)
People climb down onto the tracks close to Paddington after being stranded on a prepare final evening
An Aslef spokesman instructed MailOnline: ‘The downside is that many of those managers have not pushed a prepare for a very long time and their competence isn’t what it ought to be.
‘We noticed the consequence yesterday. Significant harm to the railway infrastructure, passengers put in danger, and critical disruption to the rail community.
‘But, I suppose, as an operations investigations supervisor, he’s uniquely certified to research his personal actions and what went mistaken.’
GWR was contacted for remark by MailOnline right this moment, and a spokesman mentioned: ‘The driver was absolutely certified driver with competence updated.
‘The solely individuals who can drive trains are competent drivers with route data and competence maintained.
‘As but, there’s completely no proof the OHLE (overhead electrical gear) fault was as a result of a prepare.’
GWR instructed passengers that considered one of its trains ‘struck an obstruction on the road inflicting harm to the overhead electrical wires’.
The Great Western fundamental line was already being investigated by the Office of Rail and Road over poor reliability.
The Aslef strikes continued right this moment with members at Northern Rail and TransPennine Express strolling out, inflicting the cancellation of all companies.
Disruption can also be anticipated tomorrow morning as rolling inventory is perhaps misplaced.
Union members have staged strikes in opposition to completely different prepare operators since final Saturday and launched a ban on time beyond regulation, which ends on Saturday.
Aslef normal secretary Mick Whelan mentioned his members stay solidly behind the marketing campaign for a rise to a pay supply made earlier this 12 months value 8 per cent over two years.
The Rail Delivery Group and the Government have urged the union to poll its members on the pay supply.
But Aslef says its members have voted in large numbers to proceed taking strike motion when they’re reballoted each six months below employment regulation.
The dispute began in June final 12 months however reveals no signal of being resolved regardless of the disruption passengers have confronted throughout waves of business motion.
![Passengers start making the long walk back in the cold to Paddington yesterday evening](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78717911-12841573-Passengers_start_making_the_long_walk_back_in_the_cold_to_Paddin-a-127_1702046114817.jpg)
Passengers begin making the lengthy stroll again within the chilly to Paddington yesterday night
![The power failure meant the lights went off inside trains while the heating also could not work](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78713237-12841573-The_power_failure_meant_the_lights_went_off_inside_trains_while_-a-128_1702046114822.jpg)
The energy failure meant the lights went off inside trains whereas the heating additionally couldn’t work
It comes after a hellish evening for commuters on Sadiq Khan ‘s creaking £19billion Elizabeth line trapped in the dead of night who in contrast it to London within the Blitz.
A spokesperson for Mr Khan instructed MailOnline right this moment: ‘This was clearly a really distressing expertise for everybody concerned. TfL are talking to Network Rail and Great Western Rail to research what occurred and are working onerous to renew regular service on the Elizabeth line as quickly as doable.’
There have been even claims of sexual touching, with a police officer telling a passenger: ‘Unfortunately we have had just a few incidents. We’ve had one arrest of sexual touching and issues like that. So issues have taken longer than presumably what they need to have executed as a result of somebody determined that they wished to the touch somebody up.’
Mikey Worrall posted footage of passengers in the dead of night and mentioned they have been opening up the doorways to get onto the road, including: ‘The Mayor of London must kind it out.’
He mentioned the frenzy hour service lurched to a cease earlier than a multiple-hour wait in semi-darkness as the driving force drip-fed what little info they needed to passengers.
Eventually, the battery backup operating the heating and lighting ran out, and people on board have been left in darkness for an additional hour and a half till the evacuation got here.
Describing his ‘surreal night’, Mr Worrall added: ‘Every day, it is a completely different excuse. It appears to me they opened this complete factor with out truly being match for objective.
‘If they knew there have been infrastructure points that they wanted to work on, why did not they work on these earlier than? They opened the road and it would not work. It (goes down) a number of instances every week, and it is extremely irritating.’
And there have been extra issues this morning amid large questions for Mr Khan in regards to the Elizabeth line’s reliability after MailOnline revealed it had the sharpest enhance in cancellations of any UK rail route within the newest quarter in comparison with final 12 months.
Great Western Railway and Heathrow Express, which function trains on the identical routes by West London, have been additionally operating diminished companies this morning.
On the Elizabeth line right this moment, companies have been suspended between Heathrow Terminal 2&3 and Terminal 5 stations, whereas extreme delays remained between Paddington and Heathrow Terminal 2,3&4 and Reading, and between Abbey Wood and Whitechapel.
National Rail mentioned disruption on all routes was anticipated till at the least 6pm right this moment because of the persevering with effort to repair the overhead wires points within the Ladbroke Grove space.
Earlier, it had mentioned disruption would final till 12pm – and that point was then pushed again this morning till 3pm.
![Countdown's Rachel Riley was one of those stuck on board the train from 6pm last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78715705-12841573-Countdown_s_Rachel_Riley_was_one_of_those_stuck_on_board_the_tra-a-129_1702046114823.jpg)
Countdown’s Rachel Riley was a kind of caught on board the prepare from 6pm final evening
![Passengers on board one train on the Elizabeth line were stuck for hours yesterday evening](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78710425-12841573-Passengers_on_board_one_train_on_the_Elizabeth_line_were_stuck_f-a-130_1702046114823.jpg)
Passengers on board one prepare on the Elizabeth line have been caught for hours yesterday night
Transport for London (TfL) mentioned tickets have been being accepted on Underground trains, buses and different mainline rail routes together with Thameslink and Southeastern.
But the Central line was additionally hit by delays this morning as a result of a ‘scarcity of trains’, whereas there was no service on the Bakerloo line between Stonebridge Park and Harrow & Wealdstone whereas a monitor fault was mounted within the North Wembley space.
GWR issued an alert to passengers saying ‘don’t journey’ between Paddington and Reading till additional discover, saying services between Oxford or Didcot Parkway and Paddington will finish or begin again from Reading. GWR passengers in Devon between Plymouth and Totnes have been additionally instructed ‘to not journey’ after flooding blocked that line.
Countdown’s Rachel Riley was a kind of caught on board the prepare from 6pm final evening, and posted a selfie of her and different passengers smiling on board, captioned: ‘Nearly 4 hours after we acquired on, we’re getting off the Elizabeth line, woohoo!’.
Seemingly additionally amongst these trapped was singer James Blunt, who mentioned: ‘Been caught someplace outdoors Paddington for near 4 hours now. Out of peanuts and wine.’
The Elizabeth line – which opened in May 2022 – makes use of mainline rail infrastructure west of Paddington. Services have been repeatedly hit by faults in latest weeks – with 4 broken rails found in eight days final month on the Great Western line.
![People stuck on a blacked out train on the Elizabeth Line after a power failure](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78709575-12841573-People_stuck_on_a_blacked_out_train_on_the_Elizabeth_Line_after_-a-131_1702046114824.jpg)
![The only light inside the carriage was coming from their mobile phones](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78709573-12841573-The_only_light_inside_the_carriage_was_coming_from_their_mobile_-a-132_1702046114825.jpg)
Videos confirmed passengers sitting in a blacked out carriage of the 6.37pm Paddington service
![Queues at London Paddington station for taxis last night following the Elizabeth line chaos](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727673-12841573-Queues_at_London_Paddington_station_for_taxis_last_night_followi-a-133_1702046114825.jpg)
Queues at London Paddington station for taxis final evening following the Elizabeth line chaos
No trains ran between Paddington and Heathrow after the incident started final evening, with Great Western Railway and Heathrow Express companies additionally affected by delays as passengers have been stranded whereas strikes by prepare drivers’ union Aslef continued.
Those on trains have been made to attend for greater than three hours till police began evacuating carriages, with some passengers resorting to forcing the doorways open and ‘self evacuating’ earlier than emergency companies had arrived.
Footage obtained by MailOnline reveals passengers carrying heavy suitcases alongside the tracks within the pitch black darkish after they disembarked the prepare and headed again in direction of Paddington.
Passenger Mr Worrall mentioned: ‘We noticed a few staff come previous, they usually have been making an attempt to maintain everybody calm. Suddenly, we noticed a stream of individuals coming down the monitor, and at that time, it was clear that we’d be getting off.
‘It was actually eerie strolling down the railway line in amongst this massive crowd of individuals. It felt like a wartime factor.’
Amid traumatic scenes, aged folks, youngsters and even the chief govt of Network Rail have been amongst these caught on carriages the place temperatures plummeted when the heating stopped working because of the energy failure.
A mom carrying a new child mentioned a girl fainted on her prepare whereas one other passenger claimed folks have been compelled to make use of the tracks and even seats as bogs.
Two folks have been handled for minor accidents and discharged on the scene.
The chaos meant some passengers missed their flights from Heathrow they’d booked to see household for Christmas.
British Airways confirmed to MailOnline right this moment that it had ‘rebooked a small variety of prospects affected by the disruption to the Elizabeth line final evening’, freed from cost.
![Officials assist passengers to get down from a train stuck on the Elizabeth line last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727669-12841573-Officials_assist_passengers_to_get_down_from_a_train_stuck_on_th-a-136_1702046114827.jpg)
Officials help passengers to get down from a prepare caught on the Elizabeth line final evening
![A passenger walks with luggage inside a Heathrow Express train stuck on the route last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727667-12841573-A_passenger_walks_with_luggage_inside_a_Heathrow_Express_train_s-a-137_1702046114828.jpg)
A passenger walks with baggage inside a Heathrow Express prepare caught on the route final evening
![Passengers wait inside a train stuck on the Elizabeth line amid the chaotic scenes last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727671-12841573-Passengers_wait_inside_a_train_stuck_on_the_Elizabeth_line_amid_-a-138_1702046114829.jpg)
Passengers wait inside a prepare caught on the Elizabeth line amid the chaotic scenes final evening
![Passengers walk after being evacuated from trains stuck on the Elizabeth line last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727665-12841573-Passengers_walk_after_being_evacuated_from_trains_stuck_on_the_E-a-139_1702046114829.jpg)
Passengers stroll after being evacuated from trains caught on the Elizabeth line final evening
![Passengers sat in the dark on an Elizabeth line train outside Paddington station last night](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727835-12841573-Passengers_sat_in_the_dark_on_an_Elizabeth_line_train_outside_Pa-a-140_1702046114830.jpg)
Passengers sat in the dead of night on an Elizabeth line prepare outdoors Paddington station final evening
Meanwhile staff have been unable to get to their late shifts as folks took to social media to vent their fury at a perceived lack of communication from TfL.
After breaking free from trains, folks have been left to attend in large queues for taxis with a purpose to get dwelling, with the rail strikes leaving many with no different transport choices.
The marketing campaign group London TravelWatch has now referred to as for an investigation after the ‘extraordinarily harmful’ incident because it condemned the ‘obvious lack of communication and gradual response time’.
A spokesman instructed MailOnline right this moment: ‘Passengers stranded on trains endured nightmare journeys on Thursday night.
‘You can think about how disagreeable it will need to have been for folks caught for greater than three hours – as energy was reduce the trains turned chilly and darkish.
‘The obvious lack of communication and gradual response time to get passengers off to a spot of security is simply as regarding.
‘We have heard studies that some passengers even tried to open the doorways themselves to self-evacuate.
‘This is extraordinarily harmful which is why clear info, and a swift coordinated response is a should in emergency conditions like this.
‘We count on TfL Elizabeth line, Network Rail and different authorities concerned to research this incident totally.
‘Lessons have to be discovered so if this form of factor does ever occur once more, each the communication and response is vastly improved.’
Transport Secretary Mark Harper mentioned on X final evening: ‘Aware of a critical incident involving overhead wires outdoors Paddington, with quite a lot of trains stationary on the tracks.’
TfL apologised for the disruption, however it was not resolved by the morning – with passengers urged to examine earlier than they journey.
Engineers labored by the evening to get two of the 4 traces serving Paddington open for electrical trains.
Morning commuters right this moment have been warned their journeys could also be delayed by as much as 90 minutes.
A Network Rail spokesman mentioned: ‘We are so sorry for the troublesome journeys passengers endured on our railway final evening and we will likely be investigating how and why it occurred.
‘The knock-on results from final evening imply operators will be unable to run a full service from Paddington right this moment and passengers ought to examine earlier than they journey.
‘Repairs are ongoing and we hope to have the railway absolutely open by the weekend.’
And a TfL spokesman instructed MailOnline: ‘We’re sorry that the harm brought about to Network Rail’s overhead energy traces by one other rail operator’s prepare has brought about important disruption to our Elizabeth line prospects in addition to all prepare operators out of London Paddington.
‘We labored to get prospects off of stranded trains as rapidly as doable and to supply any help wanted.
‘Network Rail are persevering with to urgently to restore the facility traces and we would encourage all prospects to examine earlier than they journey whereas they do that.’
Paramedics and a hazardous response group from the London Ambulance Service have been despatched to the Paddington space final evening.
A distressed mom mentioned her daughter suffers with debilitating nervousness and had been on board her prepare for 3 hours. She vented her frustration at TfL for failing to replace her.
‘She [my daughter] suffers with debilitating nervousness and has poor comprehension, to not point out bladder points which means she wants the john and is freezing chilly,’ she instructed MailOnline.
‘She will not ask for assist. No info is being given. TfL hold reducing me off on the level of answering and all I need is info that I can simplify for her.’
One passenger boarded a prepare at Acton Main Line at 6.41pm which stopped inside 5 minutes and was nonetheless ready to be rescued greater than two hours later.
Another passenger dramatically described it as ‘just like the Fall of Saigon’ and the Elizabeth line ‘has failed once more simply when passengers wanted it most’.
Dr Bamo Nouri was a kind of caught and mentioned the road had ‘nearly utterly blacked out’.
Dr Nouri wrote on X: ‘Elizabeth line has nearly utterly blacked out with a completely loaded set of carriages and lots of standing. No actual or substantial updates, no sense of urgency – been sat for nearly an hour!’
Another pissed off commuter mentioned: ‘The Elizabeth Line has failed once more simply when passengers wanted it most. At Paddington there have been previous folks, folks with infants with completely no approach of getting dwelling.
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727159-12841573-image-a-141_1702046114831.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727103-12841573-image-a-142_1702046114832.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727107-12841573-image-a-143_1702046114832.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727109-12841573-image-a-144_1702046114833.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727099-12841573-image-a-145_1702046114834.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727105-12841573-image-a-146_1702046114835.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78727101-12841573-image-a-147_1702046114836.jpg)
‘It was just like the Fall of Saigon, besides in that case some fortunate folks truly managed to get on the helicopter.’
One eyewitness claimed on X a prepare forward had hit some overhead traces, whereas one other mentioned a prepare driver needed to shout at passengers making an attempt to get off the prepare.
A video confirmed passengers sitting in a blacked out carriage of the 6.37pm Paddington service with their faces being lit up by the glow from their cellphones.
Danny Cowan, a voiceover artist who has appeared on Channel 4 and Netflix, was making his solution to his agent’s Christmas occasion when the prepare got here to sudden halt greater than an hour in the past.
He wrote on X the heating had gone off and he was so chilly he may barely assume.
He mentioned: ‘Hey any concern you would possibly get this FREEZING COLD (no heating) Elizabeth Line prepare shifting that is been caught outdoors Acton for over an hour now?
‘The driver has already needed to shout at passengers who’re making an attempt to get off. Some info could be good.’
Emma Bentley mentioned she was caught between Paddington and Acton, including: ‘The carriages have now misplaced energy, and it appears we could also be strolling dwelling…’
Another stranded passenger was having his endurance examined and wrote: ‘We haven’t any energy, so cannot transfer! I would like a pee – thoughts over matter!’
A London Ambulance Service spokesman instructed MailOnline: ‘We have been referred to as at 7.38pm yesterday to studies of numerous passengers delayed on trains between Paddington and Ladbroke Grove, west London.
‘We despatched quite a lot of sources to the scene together with an ambulance crew, a paramedic in a quick response automotive, an incident response officer and members of our Hazardous Area Response Team.
‘We handled two sufferers for minor accidents and discharged them on the scene.’
Some passengers identified that they’d additionally been hit with a overcharge fare of £8.80 from TfL as a result of they’d exceeded its ‘most journey time’ whereas caught on the prepare.
One posted an image of the overpayment on X, saying: ‘TfL are you able to refund me for my AWFUL journey yesterday? #TfL #ElizabethLine.’
Another X consumer added: Imagine the Elizabeth Line holding you hostage for over 3 hours… for TfL to nonetheless take £13 out of your account at 3am.’
Passengers are usually capable of declare a refund for a mistaken overpayment cost through the use of their on-line TfL account or calling the shopper companies hotline.
But others vowed to by no means use Elizabeth line companies once more – and additional folks insisted they’d by no means sit down after passengers have been mentioned to have urinated on seats.
![Passengers left in the dark on board a train last night as one huddles over their suitcase](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78713161-12841573-Passengers_left_in_the_dark_on_board_a_train_last_night_as_one_h-a-148_1702046114837.jpg)
Passengers left in the dead of night on board a prepare final evening as one huddles over their suitcase
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78716329-12841573-image-a-149_1702046114838.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78716331-12841573-image-a-150_1702046114839.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78708281-12841573-image-a-151_1702046114840.jpg)
![An overhead power failure to to damage wires has left people stranded on packed carriages on the Elizabeth Line tonight](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78708283-12841573-An_overhead_power_failure_to_to_damage_wires_has_left_people_str-a-152_1702046114840.jpg)
An overhead energy failure to to wreck wires has left folks stranded on packed carriages on the Elizabeth Line tonight
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78708807-12841573-image-a-153_1702046114841.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78709819-12841573-image-a-154_1702046114842.jpg)
One mentioned: ‘So going ahead, for these of you who ceaselessly use the Elizabeth line, how are you aware you are not sitting in a wee wee seat?’
Another replied: ‘I’m by no means sitting once more or going close to the entrance or again corners Imma simply hover in doorways and p**s everybody off from being in the best way however at the least I’m know I’m cleanest.’
An additional X consumer mentioned: ‘All of a sudden after studying what occurred final evening, I not want to use the Elizabeth Line the following time I’m in London. Even if it does get me from Liverpool Street to Paddington lots faster.’
It comes after MailOnline reported yesterday that the Elizabeth line had suffered the largest drop in reliability of all UK rail operators – cementing its place as considered one of Britain’s worst prepare companies.
The Crossrail community in London had a cancellation rating of 5.2 per cent for July to September, in response to new knowledge from the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) regulator.
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728577-12841573-image-a-155_1702046114842.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728589-12841573-image-a-156_1702046114843.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728571-12841573-image-a-157_1702046114844.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728573-12841573-image-a-158_1702046114845.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728583-12841573-image-a-159_1702046114845.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728607-12841573-image-a-160_1702046114846.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728601-12841573-image-a-161_1702046114847.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728611-12841573-image-a-162_1702046114847.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728613-12841573-image-a-163_1702046114848.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728615-12841573-image-a-164_1702046114849.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728609-12841573-image-a-165_1702046114849.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728617-12841573-image-a-166_1702046114850.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728595-12841573-image-a-167_1702046114851.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78728599-12841573-image-a-168_1702046114852.jpg)
Some 91,122 Elizabeth line trains have been deliberate to function by the capital over this era, which means 4,740 would have did not run both utterly or partially.
This rating fell 3.3 share factors on the identical interval final 12 months – by far the largest drop, forward of Northern slipping 1.5 factors and Great Western Railway 0.8 factors.
The Elizabeth line’s rating was the fourth worst of any operator – behind Northern at 5.6 per cent, Grand Central at 6.7 per cent and CrossCounty at 7.5 per cent.
However, the ORR did level out that the info ought to be thought of within the context of a rise in companies on the Elizabeth line in comparison with the identical time final 12 months.
The rating represents the variety of trains which are cancelled as a share of companies deliberate, together with trains lacking stations or not reaching their vacation spot.
MailOnline additionally revealed in October how main reliability points have been persevering with to plague the Elizabeth line which opened solely 19 months in the past.
Passengers have been complaining for months in regards to the commonly poor service, with some caught on trains in tunnels and others stranded on packed station platforms.
Following this web site’s investigation, Mayor Sadiq Khan apologised for the issues and admitted the service was ‘not ok’.
Earlier yesterday, there have been additionally separate issues – with no service between Heathrow terminals and Hayes and Harlington this morning whereas Network Rail mounted a monitor fault within the space of the airport.
One commuter tweeted TfL yesterday morning to say: ‘Elizabeth line all eastbound delayed then cancelled, frozen to demise ready on platform.’
![Office of Rail and Road data on the cancellations score by operator from July to September 2023 and the percentage point (pp) change compared with the same period last year](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78692891-12841573-Office_of_Rail_and_Road_data_on_the_cancellations_score_by_opera-a-135_1702046114827.jpg)
Office of Rail and Road knowledge on the cancellations rating by operator from July to September 2023 and the proportion level (pp) change in contrast with the identical interval final 12 months
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76754619-12841573-image-a-170_1702046114853.jpg)
Another mentioned: ‘Another week one other delay on the Elizabeth line, thanks TfL.’ He added: ‘When will you kind this out correctly? People’s lives are usually not a joke. Do you recognize we now have to get to work?’
A 3rd tweeted that ‘travelling seems like a continuing slap within the face’, including: ‘Station workers say they usually additionally haven’t any concept about delays so cannot reply questions.’
As the ORR launched the info yesterday, it additionally mentioned the statistics on a nationwide stage present ‘Britain’s railway continues to be not delivering constantly punctual and dependable journeys’.
It mentioned that the general stage of cancellations stays excessive, at 3.5 per cent of passenger companies within the newest quarter – though this was a marginal fall of 0.6 share factors in contrast with the identical time final 12 months.
Meanwhile 69.2 per cent of passenger trains have been on time, up 1.5 share factors on the identical quarter final 12 months.
The ORR mentioned that Network Rail was exhibiting general enchancment between June and October this 12 months, however ‘there’s way more nonetheless to do to make sure constant supply of prepare companies for passengers and freight throughout the nation’.
The regulator urged Network Rail to ‘proceed to give attention to efficiency of the infrastructure’, however added: ‘Network Rail can not ship higher journeys alone; prepare operators even have a job to play.
‘For instance, greater than half of cancelled trains are prepare operator associated. The regulator notably needs to see Network Rail main the entire {industry} in enhancing the processes that underpin punctuality and reliability, together with making widespread use of modern initiatives that the corporate and {industry} companions have developed with public funding to enhance timetabling.’
The ORR added that it has ‘considerations about efficiency within the Wales and Western area’ and has just lately begun an investigation into this.
![Commuters pack Bond Street station's platform during Elizabeth line disruption on October 9](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76382475-12841573-Commuters_pack_Bond_Street_station_s_platform_during_Elizabeth_l-a-172_1702046114855.jpg)
Commuters pack Bond Street station’s platform throughout Elizabeth line disruption on October 9
![Rail passengers wait for updates at Canary Wharf Elizabeth line station on October 12](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76751783-12841573-Rail_passengers_wait_for_updates_at_Canary_Wharf_Elizabeth_line_-a-173_1702046114856.jpg)
Rail passengers look forward to updates at Canary Wharf Elizabeth line station on October 12
Feras Alshaker, director of planning and efficiency on the ORR, mentioned yesterday: ‘As the impartial regulator, the info we’re publishing right this moment bears out the truth that passengers in some areas are nonetheless experiencing trains not constantly arriving on time, and excessive ranges of cancellations.
‘However, we’re starting to see indicators of enchancment in Network Rail’s contribution. While these enhancements are promising, they are not constant, and as our evaluation reveals, the corporate can do way more to make sure that Britain’s railway supplies a dependable and punctual service for all its customers.
‘We recognise that making certain trains run as deliberate and to time requires cross-industry collaboration. Network Rail can play a vital half in bringing the rail {industry} collectively to construct on latest efficiency enhancements and we are going to work with authorities to strengthen these relationships.’
Concerns over the Elizabeth line have intensified in latest months with MailOnline revealing disruption was reported each day between Monday and Friday on one week in October.
These included three damaged down trains at Paddington, a monitor fault within the central part, a sign failure at Tottenham Court Road and a monitor inspection within the west.
Amid mounting requires an investigation, Mr Khan revealed TfL commissioner Andrew Lord had ‘taken private cost’ of enhancing the service.
The Mayor additionally admitted that the road was ‘not good’, including: ‘The commissioner himself apologised for the service commuters obtained and I echo that apology.’
It comes after opposition politicians instructed Mr Khan to ‘dig down into the supply of this disruption’ and be ‘pushing’ TfL to urgently ship infrastructure enhancements.
![Passengers on the Elizabeth line face disruption at Hayes and Harlington station on October 1](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76382469-12841573-Passengers_on_the_Elizabeth_line_face_disruption_at_Hayes_and_Ha-a-175_1702046114857.jpg)
Passengers on the Elizabeth line face disruption at Hayes and Harlington station on October 1
![Huge queues at Woolwich station amid Elizabeth line disruption in London on September 11](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76382473-12841573-Huge_queues_at_Woolwich_station_amid_Elizabeth_line_disruption_i-a-176_1702046114858.jpg)
Huge queues at Woolwich station amid Elizabeth line disruption in London on September 11
The line was meant to supply a quick route between Heathrow and Reading within the west and Shenfield and Abbey Wood within the east by 26 miles of recent tunnels.
But disruption is now an nearly day by day incidence, with excuses for delays starting from monitor faults to damaged trains and signalling points to overhead cable issues.
Mr Khan instructed MyLondon in October: ‘We raised this on the final TfL board assembly final week and the commissioner himself has taken private cost of this.
‘The excellent news is it is a prepare line that is the most well-liked prepare line within the nation. More than 3.5 million journeys every week. But it is not good.’
He added that bosses have been talking to Network Rail about enhancements to points west of Paddington and east of Liverpool Street as a result of ‘these traces aren’t TfL traces – they’re Network Rail traces.’
Asked if the service will likely be improved, Mr Khan added: ‘No complacency, however Londoners, and people throughout the nation who use the Elizabeth line, are receiving the most effective service within the nation in the case of the standard of service.
‘But it is not ok – and that is one of many the explanation why I’m actually happy the TfL commissioner himself is trying into this… seeing what extra that may be executed to regularise the service.’
Elizabeth line director Howard Smith instructed MailOnline in October that bosses ‘sincerely apologise for the disruption’ and understood that delays had been ‘irritating’ for patrons.
He added that TfL had been ‘urgently reviewing latest incidents’ and was working with Network Rail and Alstom, which maintains the trains, to enhance the service.
![Passengers are packed onto an Elizabeth line train through London at 8pm on September 25](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76382477-12841573-Passengers_are_packed_onto_an_Elizabeth_line_train_through_Londo-a-178_1702046114859.jpg)
Passengers are packed onto an Elizabeth line prepare by London at 8pm on September 25
![Passengers wait outside the ticket gates at Woolwich Elizabeth line station on October 16](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76751781-12841573-Passengers_wait_outside_the_ticket_gates_at_Woolwich_Elizabeth_l-a-179_1702046114860.jpg)
Passengers wait outdoors the ticket gates at Woolwich Elizabeth line station on October 16
Mr Khan’s apology got here after mounting fury in regards to the state of the road, each from passengers and politicians.
Labour MP Rupa Huq mentioned she nonetheless used the London Underground to commute from Ealing as a substitute of the Elizabeth line as a result of she has ‘all too usually been disillusioned’ by delays on the brand new line.
Ms Huq, who represents Ealing Central and Acton in West London, instructed MailOnline in October: ‘When it really works it is nice, however I’ve to say I’ve caught to good previous London Underground for my day by day commute as I’ve all too usually been disillusioned by Elizabeth line delays which constituents frequently e-mail me about.
‘Most annoying is the truth that trains are inclined to skip Acton Main Line which appears to be a forgotten station regardless of its refit, and the opposite day my staffer was late to work in Ealing Broadway as all trains have been terminating at Paddington.
‘I’m undecided if that is teething troubles as when I’ve raised it with them, TfL have mentioned to bear with them, enhancements are on the best way – however they can not come quickly sufficient.’
Transport watchdog London TravelWatch has referred to as for a gathering with senior TfL operations workers to debate what will be executed to enhance companies.
A spokesman mentioned: ‘Passengers fairly rightly count on a punctual and dependable service however there have been some actually difficult incidents just lately.
‘We’re searching for assurances from TfL that there are sturdy plans in place to handle the problems at hand – together with defective prepare doorways, signalling and disruptive emergency engineering work.’
In October some passengers claimed they have been caught for 40 minutes underground as a result of damaged prepare doorways , whereas others ended up being greater than an hour late into the workplace as a result of emergency engineering works that needed to be carried out because of the monitor downside.
![London Mayor Sadiq Khan embraces Transport for London Commissioner Andy Byford as they travel on the first eastbound train on the Elizabeth Line from Paddington on May 24, 2022](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/70815583-12841573-London_Mayor_Sadiq_Khan_embraces_Transport_for_London_Commission-a-181_1702046114861.jpg)
London Mayor Sadiq Khan embraces Transport for London Commissioner Andy Byford as they journey on the primary eastbound prepare on the Elizabeth Line from Paddington on May 24, 2022
![Mayor of London Sadiq Khan poses for a selfie on the first Elizabeth line train on May 24, 2022](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/58215433-12841573-Mayor_of_London_Sadiq_Khan_poses_for_a_selfie_on_the_first_Eliza-a-182_1702046114862.jpg)
Mayor of London Sadiq Khan poses for a selfie on the primary Elizabeth line prepare on May 24, 2022
That compounded the distress on the finish of every week plagued by delays – leaving some commuters calling for a serious investigation into what goes mistaken.
Before it even launched in May final 12 months, the Crossrail mission suffered quite a few points together with building difficulties and issues putting in signalling methods which delayed the opening a number of instances.
This was a lot to the frustration of many owners shopping for properties alongside the route in the course of the building interval within the hope of getting a neater commute.
In 2007, the road was given a gap date of December 2017, and set a funds of £14.8billion in 2010.
But the estimated last value was £18.9billion, together with £5.1billion from the Government – making it greater than £4billion over funds.
In 2010, the opening was pushed again by a 12 months to happen in December 2018 – however simply 4 months earlier than this date, in August 2018, it was introduced that the road would the truth is not open on time.
Four years later the Elizabeth line did finally open in May 2022 – however solely in three sections, with companies on the brand new half from Paddington to Abbey Wood.
Existing companies from Reading and Heathrow to Paddington, and from Shenfield to Liverpool Street, have been additionally rebranded from ‘TfL Rail’ to the ‘Elizabeth line’ at this level.
The grand opening was lengthy awaited, and its first service from Paddington noticed worldwide rail fans travelling to the capital and queueing for greater than six hours to get on board – with Mr Khan pictured hugging TfL officers in delight.
However the primary day was additionally blighted by a hearth alarm being activated which noticed Paddington evacuated. The disruption was clearly an indication of issues to return.
The line initially opened in three sections – from Reading/Heathrow to Paddington, Liverpool Street to Shenfield and the brand new Paddington to Abbey Wood half.
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78687677-12841573-image-a-184_1702046114863.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78687679-12841573-image-a-185_1702046114864.jpg)
![](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/78687675-12841573-image-a-186_1702046114864.jpg)
Then in November final 12 months, the second stage started which noticed by trains begin operating from Reading and Heathrow to Abbey Wood; and Shenfield to Paddington.
The last stage from May this 12 months noticed companies begin operating from Shenfield to Heathrow, in addition to the present Reading and Heathrow to Abbey Wood providing.
But MailOnline revealed in March that there would no direct trains from Shenfield to Reading, regardless of TfL beforehand heralding the road as a ‘new east-west railway’ – with trains from Shenfield as a substitute forking off after Hayes and Harlington to terminate at Heathrow.
It additionally emerged that at Acton Main Line and Hanwell, there could be nearly no direct companies to Shenfield or Reading – with these West London stations solely served by trains between Abbey Wood and Heathrow each quarter-hour, as they beforehand have been earlier than the change.
Days earlier than the timetable change on May 21 this 12 months, there was main disruption on May 16 that noticed rush-hour passengers trapped on a service for 75 minutes.
The delay was so lengthy that one passenger allegedly needed to urinate on the carriage ground as a result of there are not any bogs on board the trains.
Since May 21, the road has been affected by additional reliability points and ongoing rail strikes.
Network Rail has apologised for the poor service, notably out of Paddington, amid mounting fury.
Major points occurred on July 25 when the western part of the route was hit by a serious Network Rail signalling system outage.
![People queue for the Elizabeth line at Paddington station before the first train on May 24, 2022](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/58215351-12841573-People_queue_for_the_Elizabeth_line_at_Paddington_station_before-a-188_1702046114866.jpg)
People queue for the Elizabeth line at Paddington station earlier than the primary prepare on May 24, 2022
![The first passengers for the Elizabeth line at Paddington go down an escalator on May 24, 2022](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/58215341-12841573-The_first_passengers_for_the_Elizabeth_line_at_Paddington_go_dow-a-189_1702046114867.jpg)
The first passengers for the Elizabeth line at Paddington go down an escalator on May 24, 2022
This severely impacted companies for 2 days and meant trains weren’t capable of simply get to and from the Old Oak Common depot, situated in Acton close to the proposed HS2 station.
Another main downside occurred on August 16 when a upkeep prepare leaked hydraulic fluid inside the central tunnel part of the road.
This fluid needed to be cleaned from greater than 1.2 miles (2km) of monitor earlier than TfL may safely run once more companies.
The line was half suspended from Abbey Wood to Whitechapel for many of that day, which severely restricted the variety of trains that might run.
In September, the ORR revealed Elizabeth line cancellations had hit 9.1 per cent within the 4 weeks to August 19 – the worst determine for any UK rail service over that interval.
Going again to May 2022 when it began operating, the Elizabeth line carried out comparatively effectively in its opening months, with a cancellation fee of two.5 per cent or under for the primary 5 months.
But it then had a poor 4 weeks as much as December 10 final 12 months when the speed hit 3.9 per cent – and for the 4 weeks ending March 31 this 12 months, the speed hit 4.3 per cent.
The common disruption has incensed commuters, with many taking to social media to voice their frustration at how the road appears to be disrupted nearly each day.
In October, TfL warned that ‘important challenges’ will proceed on the road’s 41-station community till new rail infrastructure is put in – with work on new overhead energy traces not anticipated to begin till subsequent 12 months on the earliest.
![Prince William and Kate travelled on the Elizabeth line from Acton Main Line on May 4](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/76942781-12841573-Prince_William_and_Kate_travelled_on_the_Elizabeth_line_from_Act-a-191_1702046114868.jpg)
Prince William and Kate travelled on the Elizabeth line from Acton Main Line on May 4
Network Rail has spoken to {industry} consultants and part producers to work out what goes mistaken because it tries to enhance signalling gear and operations.
They are notably involved about points within the western part of the road – a part of which was designed by Isambard Kingdom Brunel and constructed within the 1830s.
Officials are hoping to modernise overhead energy cables between Paddington and Heathrow Airport, with work set to happen between 2024 and 2029.
However, this nonetheless requires last funding approval from the ORR.
And, if it goes forward, it’ll seemingly lead to main closures because of the engineering works required to improve the system.
But the road has been an enormous success for TfL by way of utilization, with it having carried greater than 200 million passengers since launching in May 2022.
The busiest day on the Elizabeth line since opening was earlier this week – Wednesday, December 6 – with greater than 769,000 journeys.
More than 150million passenger journeys have been made in its first 12 months, with 56 per cent of those on the peak instances of 7am to 10am and 4pm to 7pm on weekdays.
TfL claimed in July that the Elizabeth line was accountable for 140,000 ‘new’ journeys in London every day, and mentioned greater than a 3rd of those that have switched from the Underground preferring it over the Central line.
Bosses additionally insist that the Elizabeth line commonly has one of many highest buyer satisfaction scores of all of the TfL modes of transport.
![The line runs from Heathrow and Reading in the west to Shenfield and Abbey Wood in the east](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2023/12/08/14/68642233-12841573-The_line_runs_from_Heathrow_and_Reading_in_the_west_to_Shenfield-a-193_1702046114870.jpg)
The line runs from Heathrow and Reading within the west to Shenfield and Abbey Wood within the east
And the organisation factors out that the Elizabeth line was second finest for punctuality nationally out of 24 UK rail operators within the newest interval with 82.8 per cent of trains listed as ‘on time’ by ORR metrics.
But in October, the Evening Standard reported on a TfL customer support and operational efficiency panel assembly at which it was mentioned how ‘important challenges’ are anticipated on the road till new rail infrastructure is put in.
Elizabeth line director Mr Smith mentioned on the time that renewing this ‘will not be a fast repair’ and that work will proceed ‘subsequent 12 months and the 12 months past’.
Sophie Bancroft, operations director of Network Rail’s western routes, added: ‘It’s not a fast repair [but] it is not going to be horrible for years.’
Rail commuters throughout Britain have additionally endured months of distress due to common prepare strikes – whereas these in London confronted a 5.9 per cent common rise in transport fares in March.
Tube and bus fares are additionally anticipated to rise by round 4 per cent subsequent 12 months.
A TfL report in October identified that the ‘reliability of the trains has been under goal’, though it mentioned this has improved in latest weeks following software program upgrades, regardless of nonetheless being under goal.
In addition, the report claimed the largest ongoing points are more likely to be within the western part between Paddington and Reading and Heathrow.
It mentioned: ‘The most important challenges are more likely to stay with Network Rail’s Western infrastructure, regardless of all of the work undertaken by Network Rail colleagues because the underlying infrastructure isn’t in a passable state and a programme of renewals is deliberate.’
But the report additionally mentioned demand was surging, with some stations that existed earlier than being related to the Elizabeth line now seeing double the variety of passengers in comparison with pre-pandemic ranges after connectivity improved.
It cited entries and exits at West Ealing in West London which have elevated from 22,000 in 2019 to 45,000 in October.
While the Elizabeth line a TfL-branded service, the community is technically operated by an organization referred to as MTR Elizabeth line (MTREL), which is a 100 per cent subsidiary of an organization based mostly in Hong Kong referred to as MTR (Mass Transit Railway) Corporation.
Despite the road’s points, the agency received rail operator of the 12 months on the UK National Transport Awards in London on October 5.
A TfL spokesman instructed MailOnline yesterday: ‘The Elizabeth line has been one of the widespread and punctual railways within the nation since opening.
‘There are round 4.3 million passenger journeys now happening every week and there have been greater than 270 million journeys because it was opened, however we sincerely apologise for the disruption that has affected some Elizabeth line companies in latest months and we recognise that delays and cancellations are irritating for our prospects.
‘From July to August 2023, the Elizabeth line had the second finest punctuality within the nation, and though cancellations are greater than we wish and better than the identical interval in 2022, we elevated companies in each November 2022 and May 2023, offering additional, extra direct companies for our prospects.
‘We are working with Network Rail and Alstom, which maintains the trains, to minimise the impression that faults have on the Elizabeth line.
‘Recent signalling and infrastructure points on Network Rail monitor within the west has had a big impression on reliability, as produce other points similar to trespassers on the road.
‘We will proceed to do all we are able to to drive down delays so we are able to present our prospects a secure and dependable railway.’
** Were YOU caught on an Elizabeth line prepare? Do you’re employed for TfL and Network Rail and know what is going on mistaken? Please e-mail: [email protected] **