London24NEWS

Author whose e-book title was misquoted by healthcare boss’s murderer sparks fury with shock profiteering posts

The author of a book tied to the assassination of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson is drawing fury online after using the shooting to generate sales. 

Author Jay M. Feinman’s 2010 book ‘Delay, Deny, Defend’, details ‘why insurance companies don’t pay claims and what you can do about it.’

Attention was brought onto the 14-year-old publication after bullet casings left at the scene of health insurance boss Thompson, 50, were scrawled with words ‘depose’, ‘deny’ and ‘defend‘ – extremely similar to Feinman’s title. 

Thompson was shot in the back and calf early on Wednesday morning by a masked man who fled on a bike, before the CEO succumbed to his injuries in hospital.

When Feinman was contacted by DailyMail.com for his take, he simply responded ‘no comment.’ 

But plenty are now commenting on how Feinman has taken it upon himself to use the opportunity to promote the reprinting of the $10.99 bestseller. 

‘Amazon is being restocked. About a week,’ he tweeted in one message on Friday evening. 

But only minutes later he felt the need to tweet yet again touting his 197 page book.

Author Jay M. Feinman is drawing fury online as he as posted a series of tweets in which he has shamelessly promoted how his out of print work is to once again be restocked by Amazon
The title of a 2010 book by Jay M. Feinman criticizing insurance practices bears resemblance to messages on shell casings found at the scene of the crime

Author Jay M. Feinman is drawing fury online as he as posted a series of tweets in which he has shamelessly promoted how his out of print work is to once again be restocked by Amazon

Feinman posted several tweets in which he shamelessly promoted how his out of print work is to once again be restocked by Amazon

Feinman posted several tweets in which he shamelessly promoted how his out of print work is to once again be restocked by Amazon

Feinman's tactless plug appeared to irk many online users

Feinman’s tactless plug appeared to irk many online users

'Hmm. I wonder why it’s sold out??' added another with a knowing message

‘Hmm. I wonder why it’s sold out??’ added another with a knowing message

‘Because folks have been asking: Delay, Deny, Defend paperback out of stock on Amazon. the only source. Restock soon. Kindle available,’ he wrote.

But the tactless plug appeared to irk many online users. 

‘Are you really attempting to profit on an assassination? Bide your time and count your money later,’ wrote one in response. 

‘Hmm. I wonder why it’s sold out??’ added another with a knowing message.

Feinman is a law professor at Rutgers University. It’s unclear whether he had any personal impetus to write the book. 

It explains how the health insurance industry routinely puts claimants off with bureaucratic tactics and, in the end, never end up paying out. 

Police are yet to confirm the gunman’s identity or motive.  

On Saturday night, the NYPD released new pictures of the healthcare CEO’s assassin late Saturday night as the huge manhunt entered its fifth day.

One of the images show the killer - who has a fresh coat and face mask on - walking down a Manhattan sidewalk

One of the images show the killer – who has a fresh coat and face mask on – walking down a Manhattan sidewalk

The suspect was picked up on 86th Street and Columbus Avenue two minutes after he left Central Park in Manhattan's Upper West Side

The suspect was picked up on 86th Street and Columbus Avenue two minutes after he left Central Park in Manhattan’s Upper West Side

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was shot dead on Wednesday morning

UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson was shot dead on Wednesday morning 

The bag was found by cops on their second sweep of the park and was placed between boulders just south of the park's carousel

The bag was found by cops on their second sweep of the park and was placed between boulders just south of the park’s carousel 

One of the images show the killer – who is wearing a fresh coat and has a face mask on – cowering inside the back of a cab while the other sees him outside the vehicle on the road.

The images appear to have been taken inside the taxi which picked him up on 86th Street and Columbus Avenue two minutes after he left Central Park in Manhattan’s Upper West Side.

‘There had been some threats,’ Paulette Thompson, 51, told NBC News as she broke her silence in her first comments since her husband was killed.

‘I don’t know details. I just know that he said there were some people that had been threatening him’ before his trip to New York, she added.

Ms Thompson said that she could not ‘really give a thoughtful response right now’ as she had ‘just found this out’ and was ‘trying to console [her] children’.

She said police had told her it is believed to have been a ‘targeted attack’.

Brian Thompson, 50, was shot in the calf and back early on Wednesday by a masked man who appeared to be waiting for him outside the Hilton hotel.

Shocking footage showed the gunman approach Mr Thompson from several feet and shoot, causing him to fall.

The gunman fired multiple shots during the ambush and jammed his gun in the process, but managed to quickly clear the obstruction and continue firing.

After the assailant darted across the road and out of sight, Mr Thompson was rushed to Mt Sinai Hospital in critical condition, where he was later pronounced dead.

No arrests have yet been made. 

Police sources told ABC News that casings were found at the scene with the cryptic messages left on them.

Police said they found three live 9mm rounds and three discharged 9mm shell casings, as well as a cellphone, at the scene.

As Thompson stumbled down the street, a witness in the hotel's entryway sprinted away

As Thompson stumbled down the street, a witness in the hotel’s entryway sprinted away 

Police sources told ABC News that casings were found at the scene with the cryptic messages left on them

Police sources told ABC News that casings were found at the scene with the cryptic messages left on them

Bullets lie on the sidewalk at the scene outside the Hilton Hotel in midtown Manhattan where Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, was fatally shot, Wednesday, December 4

Bullets lie on the sidewalk at the scene outside the Hilton Hotel in midtown Manhattan where Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, was fatally shot, Wednesday, December 4

Detectives are now working to determine the meaning as they try to assess what the motive for the shooting may have been.

Timeline of shooting 

6:44am – Thompson is shot as he walked towards the New York Hilton

6:46am – Police respond to a 911 call saying a person was shot

6:48am – Thompson is taken to hospital as the gunman fled on bicycle

7:12am – Thompson is pronounced dead at Mt Sinai West hospital 

Advertisement

Nothing has been confirmed yet, and the shooter is still on the loose at the time of writing.

Crime Stoppers is offering a $10,000 reward for information.

There is nothing to suggest Delay Deny Defend author Jay M. Feinman had any connection to the attack.

Online commentators were quick to point that the words found on the casings resembled insurance terminology and tactics.

One noted difference is that the book has ‘delay’ in its title, whereas one casing reportedly had ‘depose’ on it.

United is the biggest health insurer by market share in America. They have been the subject of protests by activists for allegedly systematically denying care for patients.

One such protest earlier this year led to the arrests of 11 people outside the United Healthcare headquarters in Minnetonka, Minnesota.

Police had said in their initial preliminary brief that the killer escaped into Central Park on the electric bike and released an image of the suspect on a bike after the shooting, seen here

Police had said in their initial preliminary brief that the killer escaped into Central Park on the electric bike and released an image of the suspect on a bike after the shooting, seen here

The company made headlines in February after it was subjected to a cyber-attack which cost $872 million.

Thompson was also being investigated by the Department of Justice for antitrust violations and was accused of insider trading.

The department launched a probe into whether the private company was unfairly restricting competitors and running a monopoly. 

Police sources close to the investigation told CNN that they believe the shooter was an experienced marksman based on his reactions.

Firearms experts who studied the surveillance footage told the outlet that he reacted in the way someone with training from law enforcement or military would be trained to react to such an issue.

Thompson is understood to have been in New York for a conference when he was shot.

His schedule was widely known, and witnesses have said the suspected gunman even knew which door Thompson was going to emerge from before opening fire. 

Authorities say the attacker fled the scene on foot before then making a getaway on an electric bike into nearby Central Park.

Detectives and members of the New York City police department's Crime Scene Unit at the scene where UnitedHealthcare's CEO Brian Thompson was shot and killed, on Wednesday

Detectives and members of the New York City police department’s Crime Scene Unit at the scene where UnitedHealthcare’s CEO Brian Thompson was shot and killed, on Wednesday

Law enforcement officers work near evidence markers placed where shell casings were found

Law enforcement officers work near evidence markers placed where shell casings were found

A member of the NYPD Crime Scene Unit takes a picture of a shell casing found at the scene

A member of the NYPD Crime Scene Unit takes a picture of a shell casing found at the scene

Witnesses said the gunman was seen waiting for some time outside the hotel before the shooting, and knew which door Thompson was going to emerge from before opening fire.

Surveillance footage of the shooting shows Thompson walking alone outside of the entrance to the midtown hotel when the gunman steps into frame and opens fire. 

The terrifying video shows the masked killer draw out a large gun fitted with a silencer and shoots Thompson in the back, sending the CEO stumbling down the street as he continues to fire. 

Several bystanders were seen in the footage witnessing the horror shooting, with one woman standing mere feet away from the gunman when he opened fire. 

Newly appointed police commissioner Jessica Tisch said the shooter appeared to be ‘lying in wait for several minutes’ before approaching Thompson.

Tisch added: ‘Many people passed the suspect, but he appeared to wait for his intended target’, and said that it did not ‘appear to be a random act of violence’. 

‘From watching the video, it does seem that he’s proficient in the use of firearms as he was able to clear the malfunctions pretty quickly,’ NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny said.

Surveillance from a nearby Starbucks also show the shooter inside the establishment prior to the incident.

Police sources close to the investigation told CNN that they believe the shooter was an experienced marksman based on his reactions

Police sources close to the investigation told CNN that they believe the shooter was an experienced marksman based on his reactions 

Sources told CNN that the man bought two powers bars and a bottle of water from the coffee chain.

Authorities found a phone and a water bottle near the scene that they believe is the one he bought from Starbucks, and could offer them DNA.

The phone could also provide fingerprints and, if technicians can unlock it, could give them an insight into his identity.

Officials have yet to establish a motive in the killing but sources told ABC 7 they are investigating a possible grudge against the insurance company.  

Officers also searched Thompson’s hotel room, are interviewing his UnitedHealthcare colleagues and reviewing his social media. 

He was also caught on surveillance footage loitering outside and appeared to be on the phone ten minutes before he opened fire, according to The New York Times

Thompson had been slated to speak at an investor meeting at the hotel on Wednesday morning

Thompson had been slated to speak at an investor meeting at the hotel on Wednesday morning

The Hilton sign hangs on the facade of a hotel near the scene where the CEO of UnitedHealthcare Brian Thompson was reportedly shot and killed

The Hilton sign hangs on the facade of a hotel near the scene where the CEO of UnitedHealthcare Brian Thompson was reportedly shot and killed

Thompson had been slated to speak at an investor meeting at the hotel on Wednesday morning, in which he would announce United Healthcare’s hugely profitable 2025 financial outlook – including expected revenues of more than $450 billion. 

Thompson was named UnitedHealthcare CEO in 2021 and earned a reported $10 million a year, and for several years prior he ran the Medicare business within UnitedHealthcare. 

Wednesday’s investor conference reportedly began without interruption at 8am on the second floor of the Hilton until news of the shooting began to circulate. 

Without knowing it was Thompson who was hit, one attendee told the group that ‘someone got shot outside.’ 

CEO of parent company United Healthgroup Andrew Witty is said to have halted the meeting at the hotel just after 8am upon hearing of the tragedy

He told attendees: ‘We’re dealing with a very serious medical situation with one of our team members. As a result, I’m afraid, we’re going to have to bring to a close the event.’ 

A Hilton worker, who asked to remain anonymous, told DailyMail.com in the aftermath that staff have been left shaken by the public assassination on their doorstep. 

Mr Thompson is survived by his wife and their two children who live in the family’s $1.5 million home in Maple Grove, Minnesota.

‘We are shattered to hear about the senseless killing of our beloved Brian,’ she told ABC 7 following her husband’s untimely death.

‘Brian was an incredibly loving, generous, talented man who truly lived life to the fullest and touched so many lives,’ she said.

‘Most importantly, Brian was an incredibly loving father to our two sons and will be greatly missed.

‘We appreciate your well wishes and request complete privacy as our family moves through this difficult time.’