DAN HODGES: If the Right would not unite over Brexit, Britain will sleepwalk again into the EU’s clutches
On Sunday, Boris Johnson returned to the political fray. In an intervention carefully timed to spike the guns of Andy Burnham, who was preparing to unleash a full-frontal assault on Britain’s withdrawal from the EU in his speech to the Lord Mayor’s banquet, the godfather of Brexit chided: ‘It is madness to escalate the Brexit issue as your political priority.
‘He will impale himself and his party on this point, and he needs to move off it because he won’t win – because the reality is that people are not fools’.
It was typical Boris – eloquent, punchy and politically astute. And it provoked an immediate and vicious response.
But that backlash didn’t only come from the Labour party – or from the army of bitter Remainers. Instead, it was led by Reform’s home affairs spokesman Zia Yusuf.
‘I don’t think there has been a more damaging Prime Minister in our lifetimes than Boris Johnson,’ he raged. ‘I know people say Tony Blair, and there’s a reasonable argument to be made about that, but if you look at the damage… three and a half million [migrants] when [Boris] was Prime Minister. Then you look at what happened in the years after, with the other changes he made.’
While the former PM hasn’t responded himself, Boris is broadly correct. The political challenges facing Andy Burnham if he did try to wrench Britain back into the European Union are immense.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz last month
Significant numbers of his own MPs and Ministers oppose the idea. It would enrage large swathes of the Red Wall constituency he hopes to win back in order to secure his own full five-year term. And the chaos it would create inside an administration already struggling to set out a clear strategy would be seismic.
So if the Prime Minister attempted to re-run the Brexit referendum, in almost all circumstances he would be doomed to defeat. Save for one. If the self-styled supporters of Brexit hand him victory on a plate.
A lot has been written and said over the past few months about the split on the Right, and the manner in which the ongoing war between the Conservatives and Reform is opening a path to a snap election. But that schism is now opening up another scenario. One in which the country stumbles back into Europe almost by accident.
Burnham is wary of the prospect of fighting a new referendum. He is not an EU zealot and represents a Eurosceptic seat. His pledge during the Makerfield by-election not to reopen the issue – though now redundant – indicates he recognises the political dangers.
But he also senses an opportunity. ‘It wasn’t a priority for Andy when he came into office,’ a Minister reveals to me. ‘But if you look at where the Brexit camp is at the moment. They’re basically at each other’s throats. It’s not clear how they could put a cohesive campaign together. So there’s a clear window of opportunity. Definitely to push for closer integration. And possibly to go even further.’
The extent of this division on the Right has been underlined by two separate announcements in the past week. On Friday, it emerged the old Vote Leave campaign is to be relaunched, under the new banner ‘Stay Out’. It is being run by Oliver Lewis, the former head of research for Vote Leave, with the blessing of its then director Dominic Cummings.
But then on Monday it was confirmed a second organisation, ‘Enough Official’, is set to be launched, ostensibly with the same mission. This second venture is reportedly being run by Arron Banks, a close ally of Nigel Farage. According to Reform’s leader: ‘I’ve spoken to Arron, and I’m seeing him next week, and we’re getting reactivated’.
Those involved in ‘Enough Official’ claim they are not seeking division and will work with anyone allied to the Brexit cause. They point back to 2016, where Farage operated at arms length from the official campaign, with ultimately successful results.
But it’s not 2016 any more. The last Brexit campaign was effectively carried on the shoulders of Boris Johnson – at that time a colossus who bent British politics to his will.
And while he remains a formidable operator, Covid, Partygate and the manner of his ejection from office have taken a toll. Which makes it difficult to see how the former PM could carry a new campaign – especially if those who are supposed to be on his side take to the airwaves to undermine him at every turn.
An even bigger problem relates to the leader of Reform. In 2016 Nigel Farage was a Marmite figure; loved and loathed in broadly equal measure. That is not the situation today. Only the benighted Green leader Zack Polanski can rival him in terms of public unpopularity. So if, as it appears, Farage intends to adopt an independent – and much higher – profile in any future Brexit campaign, that could have disastrous consequences.
Andy Burnham with President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen at a summit in Dublin last week
Though not as disastrous as allowing his chief lieutenants to run amok in the way they have been. As Reform’s poll lead has vanished, then cratered, Farage’s allies have turned their attention, and fire, on the Tories. This has resulted in a series of increasingly hysterical – and at times overtly extremist – attacks on Kemi Badenoch. Which again, can only serve to play into the Remainers’ hands.
Badenoch is the Brexit campaign’s trump card. She is the most popular figure on the British Right. Before today’s intervention in the Daily Mail, she had been conspicuously keeping her head down on the issue of Europe.
According to her allies this was because she had bigger fish to fry. ‘If Burnham goes for it, Kemi will be there. But at the moment she thinks he’s bluffing. So her focus is going to be focusing on the here and now – the economy, welfare, cost of living and defence,’ one told me.
This circumspection is canny. But it also masks another truth. Why should Badenoch seek to put her head above the parapet on Brexit if her opponents in Reform will simply use it as an opportunity to try to blast it off?
The reality is any future Brexit campaign should be a foregone conclusion. Britain is weary of the issue. There is no national appetite for reopening the scars of a decade ago. And if Andy Burnham tries to, then he will almost certainly be rebuffed.
Indeed, there is only one way the Remain campaign could emerge victorious: if the Brexiteers lose sight of who their real enemy is and spend all their time waging a civil war among themselves.
Yesterday Zia Yusuf did a new interview. Again, his target was not Andy Burnham or Labour, but his own Reform colleagues.
‘If you are in the category of being concerned about [former Tories], none of the above [former Tories who have joined Reform] are going to be involved in immigration policy or borders policy. There’s a reason why Nigel’s given me this brief and not them,’ he told Quite right!, a Spectator podcast.
There is now no prospect of the Right uniting to fight the next election. And if they can’t find common ground on an issue like Brexit, then Britain really could be sleepwalking back into the EU.
