Prison tutor jailed after being discovered ‘flustered’ studying lag’s love letters
Melissa Murphy, 48, was found to have exchanged racy content with an inmate at HMP Chelmsford, where she worked as a teacher training inmates for employment after their release
Melissa Murphy arrived at Chelmsford Crown Court to be sentenced on Friday (January 16)(Image: PHIL HARRIS)
A female prison tutor who had an inappropriate relationship with an inmate, involving the sharing of sexually explicit material, has been sentenced to eight months behind bars. The severity of Melissa Murphy’s offences meant that “only a custodial sentence can be justified”, Judge Jamie Sawyer declared during sentencing at Chelmsford Crown Court today.
Steamy letters between Murphy, 48, and the prisoner was discovered following her arrest in December 2023. Murphy, who police said “abused a position of trust” in her role at HMP Chelmsford, pleaded guilty to one charge of misconduct in a public office.
The court was told that handwritten notes from Murphy containing “explicit romantic and sexual content” were uncovered in the prisoner’s cell, whilst a photograph of the inmate was discovered at her home. During a disciplinary hearing she confessed to penning love letters and confining herself in a workshop with the inmate, though she denied any physical involvement; the prosecution made no suggestion of a physical relationship.
She was dismissed from her position at HMP Chelmsford, where she had worked as an instructor preparing inmates for employment following their release. Detective Constable Becky Sparrow, the investigating officer, said: “Murphy abused a position of trust by forming this inappropriate relationship.
“By definition, anyone held in prison is in a vulnerable position. It is crucial staff and prison officers do not put those they are required to help in positions such as this — she potentially put both of them at risk of harm through these actions; we now wait to hear what sentence the courts will pass.”
Murphy first met the unnamed prisoner in November 2023 and alleged that she received a letter from him shortly afterwards. Instead of reporting it, “Murphy replied and the pair exchanged several letters suggesting they had begun a relationship,” Essex Police said.
An investigation was launched when another member of the prison staff raised concerns after attempting to enter a classroom occupied solely by Murphy, previously known as Melissa O’Brien, and the inmate. The room was locked from the inside and Murphy’s keys were confiscated, according to the Mirror.
Murphy appeared to be “flustered” when the two were found. The police stated that her role “required her keys to stay attached to her person at all times to prevent any prisoners accessing these and potentially escaping”.
Following this incident, Murphy was reported and subsequently arrested. Judge Jamie Sawyer noted that Murphy requested the prisoner be brought to the workshop despite there being no scheduled class that day.
“You held a position of trust within a prison and abused that trust by engaging in a romantic relationship with a prisoner, exposing yourself to corruption and undermining confidence in the prison system,” the judge remarked. Sentencing Murphy to eight months in prison, the judge declared: “The victim here, and in my judgment there is a victim, is the public.
“Confidence in the prison system is essential. And your actions have further eroded that confidence, particularly at HMP Chelmsford.”
The judge informed Murphy she would serve up to 40 per cent of the eight-month sentence in custody. DC Sparrow added following the sentence: “The integrity of everyone working within the criminal justice system is required to keep prisoners and the public safe.
“By entering into this relationship, Murphy compromised that integrity, exploited a vulnerable man and left herself open to exploitation too. We worked closely with the security department and staff at HMP Chelmsford throughout this investigation to ensure this case was as strong as possible, and left her with no option but to plead guilty.”
For the latest breaking news and stories from across the globe from the Daily Star, sign up for our newsletters.
