Why I’m so cheesed off about Pret’s £4.50 cheddar baguette

A Pret A Manger posh cheddar baguette was as soon as my favorite workday deal with. 

The cheese is plentiful, the pickle simply the appropriate steadiness of sharp and candy, mayonnaise and cress elevate it above its excessive avenue rivals. 

But a number of months in the past, I swore I’d by no means purchase one once more — nor the rest from the ever present espresso chain.

That’s as a result of in September final 12 months, it launched a 20 per cent low cost on meals for subscribers to its Club Pret loyalty scheme.

In return for paying a good-looking £30 a month, members stand up to 5 coffees a day at no additional value — in addition to the low cost on meals.

Now, we should endure seeing two costs offered for every merchandise: the reasonable-sounding subscriber worth and the outrageous-by-comparison worth that non-subscribers should stump up until we hand over the equal of £360 a 12 months.

I couldn’t convey myself to subscribe or pay the upper worth. Handing over £4.50 for a glorified cheese sarnie feels wealthy sufficient — and a stark reminder that I ought to make my very own at residence. 

But paying that when Pret can clearly make a revenue promoting the identical sandwich for £3.60 places me off my lunch solely.

And I’m not the one one to have been rankled by Pret. Its Trustpilot account is riddled with opinions from prospects put out by excessive costs. 

It’s rated 1.9 out of 5 on the time of writing. Its web page on X, previously Twitter, is equally strewn with feedback about costs.

And in current weeks Pret enraged some subscribers by forcing them to log into the app each time they needed to say drinks or reductions. 

This stopped them having the ability to share their membership with family and friends. And glitches with the system meant some prospects struggled to log in.

Co-founder Julian Metcalfe, who bought his stake in 2018, stated his coronary heart goes out to ‘customers who feel let down’. Pret stated the problems affected a small variety of subscribers and have been resolved.

The firm can be battling a £700 million debt pile that surged throughout Covid, increased prices, a decline in workplace employees — and the problem of convincing folks squeezed by a surging value of residing to pay near £4 for a espresso.

It’s no marvel Pret introduced a boardroom shake-up final week and plans to convey again co-founder Sinclair Beecham to assist it get again on monitor.

So what went flawed? After all, when the primary outlet — in Victoria, London — was opened by the 2 college pals in 1986, it was like a breath of contemporary air on the High Street.

David Sables, chief govt of Sentinel Management Consultants, thinks Pret has executed the maths and determined it’s price barely annoying prospects like me. 

He says the subscription makes common prospects extra dedicated, making certain they arrive in each time they’re confronted with selecting between Pret and another espresso store.

The subscription was used 1.25 million occasions per week in April final 12 months, and subscribers spend near 30 per cent extra per transaction than non-subscribers, in keeping with Pret’s figures. 

‘Once you have signed up, you cannot justify going somewhere else because you have to make the subscription pay,’ Mr Sables says.

He provides that Pret subscribers spend extra as a result of they arrive in to get their ‘free’ espresso at occasions of day after they’re in all probability contemplating meals as effectively — breakfast after they’re getting their morning espresso, lunch within the afternoon. 

He provides: ‘The risk is it annoys passersby who came in occasionally but are now put off by the non-subscriber pricing model.

‘But Pret clearly decided it gains more from encouraging loyal customers than it loses from alienating those who pop in occasionally.’

However, Clive Black, a retail analyst at Shore Capital, factors out that no different espresso store use a subscription mannequin. He says: ‘Pret is trying to monetise loyalty and it’s questionable if it’s working.’

He doubts many extra folks may have the diploma of loyalty to a espresso model wanted for Pret’s subscription to develop.

The firm goals to have 500 retailers within the UK by the tip of the 12 months. But Mr Black warns: ‘The Pret brand will only travel so far beyond London and the home counties. It can never reach the level of 2-3,000 stores enjoyed by Greggs, for example.’

Richard Hyman, an adviser to the retail business, says: ‘It used to be that you could buy a coffee with money you had rolling around in your pocket or purse — it didn’t really feel like actual cash. Now, costs make you cease and suppose.’

He provides that customers perceive meals retailers have needed to put their costs up. ‘But there is a sensitivity around prices and an inflection point which retailers go beyond at their peril,’ he provides.

Today, Pret’s tuna mayo baguette prices £4.50 for non-members — or £5.40 to eat in — up from £2.99 in December 2021, whereas a flat white has risen from £2.85 to £3.90, in keeping with espresso producer UCC Coffee.

In February, Pret lower costs on a few of its best-selling objects following claims it was overcharging. 

The cheddar baguette was lower by £1 to £3.99 — though once I purchased one yesterday in High Street Kensington in London, the complete worth was £4.50.

So what may Pret do to tempt me again?

First, present they don’t seem to be as costly as we expect. After all, they’re actually not way more expensive than say Starbucks or Caffe Nero.

Second, convey again the outdated loyalty scheme — whereby baristas may sometimes give out a free espresso. 

I’ve not often felt so warmly in direction of a model as once I went right into a Pret after a tough day and was given a free croissant by a barista who stated: ‘You look like you could do with this.’

I advised everybody I spoke to that day — can you actually put a worth on good publicity like that?

Finally, Pret has upset individuals who loved sharing their subscription. This isn’t any technique to deal with somebody as you need to wait half-hour between ordering every drink, however what about providing subscribers a 20 per cent low cost on further drinks?

Do you suppose Pret A Manger provides good worth?

[email protected]