Ex-Newsnight host Emily Maitlis compares the BBC’s ‘stifling’ impartiality rules to ‘censorship’

Former Newsnight presenter Emily Maitlis has compared the BBC‘s impartiality rules to ‘censorship’.

The seasoned journalist made the astonishing swipe after she and her colleague Jon Sopel ditched the corporation together to make a daily podcast at rival broadcaster LBC in February. 

Speaking to The Observer, Maitlis said: ‘Impartiality will be really important for us here [at LBC]. We’re not trying to do shock-jock stuff. We’re not trying to scream opinions at the world. 

‘Impartiality, in its true sense, is about covering stories without fear or favour. I get nervous when impartiality is used as a way of shutting down journalists. Is it because you were asking questions you shouldn’t have been? 

‘I don’t think that’s impartiality – that’s censorship. And if your journalism is going to suffer by staying somewhere where you cannot ask those questions, what are you doing, right?’

Emily Maitlis and colleague Jon Sopel left the BBC together to make a daily podcast at Global’s LBC

Emily Maitlis conducted a bombshell interview with Prince Andrew over his links with Jeffrey Epstein while presenter of Newsnight

Maitlis had already fallen afoul of the BBC’s strict rules before leaving the broadcaster this year.

The journalist came under fire for criticising Dominic Cummings in a Newsnight monologue and retweeting messages condemning Boris Johnson. 

Meanwhile Jon Sopel, who previously worked as the BBC’s North America Editor, recalled an incident while working in the US when he filed a story while travelling with Barack Obama to the UK.

He said the BBC’s night editor called him and said the story was not impartial as it did not include anything about Nigel Farage – this was shortly before the Brexit referendum. 

‘I said, ‘I don’t think Nigel Farage was on the plane’.’

The pair’s new podcast with LBC launches next week and will be a news-focussed programme

Ms Maitlis had several run-ins with management over impartiality before she decided to leave her role, the most controversial of which was when she said Cummings had broken lockdown rules during a Newsnight programme.

She was reprimanded by the corporation, but told Press Gazette that it was never explained to her what was inaccurate about her monologue.

The pair’s podcast will be a daily news show in which they hope to focus on big stories which are not the main topic of the day.

But Ms Maitlis and Mr Sopel are not the only pair to have jumped ship in recent months.

Paul O’Grady left the corporation this week after quitting from his 14-year role on Radio 2 – with his departure coming just weeks after Steve Wright announced he was stepping down. 

Vanessa Feltz, 60, also stepped back from her shows on Radio 2 and BBC Radio London after almost 20 years at the helm.

The 60-year-old presenter, whose salary of more than £400,000 made her the BBC’s eighth-highest earner, quit her early morning breakfast show earlier this summer. 

Out with the old…? BBC big-hitters Paul O’Grady, Steve Wright and Tony Blackburn step back as Scott Mills and RuPaul’s Drag Race star Michelle Visage take the helm

THE RADIO 2 BIG-HITTERS STEPPING BACK

STEVE WRIGHT

Steve Wright announced he would stop hosting his daily afternoon programme in July

Radio 2 fans deplored the BBC’s decision to replace popular DJ Steve Wright with Radio 1’s Scott Mills as the corporation seeks to ‘try something different’.

As he exited Wogan House in July, donning a purple shirt, red striped tie and suit jacket, Wright told reporters it was ‘nice of you to come over’, adding: ‘That’s the way it goes… You know, sometimes people want you, sometimes they don’t.

‘Sometimes they want to make changes, give you another offer, and that’s okay, I understand that, I really understand that.’

TONY BLACKBURN

Tony Blackburn has also taken a step back

In June, Tony Blackburn attacked the BBC for its ‘strange’ decision to move his Radio 2 show.

The 79-year-old DJ appeared to blame the decision on ageism, saying in a post on social media ‘there’s a lot of it about’.

Blackburn criticised the ‘wacky’ decision on Twitter, and fans of the show flocked to support the former Radio 1 DJ. One commented that the BBC was ‘making a lot of mistakes’ by changing up the scheduling.

CRAIG CHARLES

Craig Charles also lost his Saturday night slot in the ongoing BBC shake-up

Craig Charles’ Radio 2 show on a Saturday night was axed as part of a major shake up of the BBC channel, sparking uproar from fans.

The star, 57, has presented his show Craig Charles’ House Party on Saturdays from 10pm to midnight since 2014.

In a series of other changes Drag Race star Michelle Visage will permanently join the station with a Friday slot from 7-9pm.

VANESSA FELTZ

In July, Vanessa Feltz quit her early morning breakfast show after nearly 20 years on air 

Also in July, Vanessa Feltz quit her early morning breakfast show after nearly 20 years on air.

Feltz said she had to step down ‘to catch up on a much-needed decade’s deficit of beauty sleep’ and use her ‘energy-boosting shut-eye’ to ‘frolic with her fiancé Ben Ofoedu ‘who irritatingly remains 10 years younger than me.’

Breaking down on her show as she announced the news to her listeners, the star said she would ‘try not to cry’.

PAUL O’GRADY

Paul O’Grady quit his 14-year stint on BBC Radio 2 and had hit last show on August 14

Paul O’Grady said he quit his 14-year stint on BBC Radio 2 saying he ‘wasn’t really happy’ as he was forced to share his slot with comedian Rob Beckett as he becomes the last star to leave the corporation. 

The TV and radio presenter, 67, hosted his last Sunday evening 5-7pm slot in August after he began presenting the show in 2009. 

A shake-up saw him regularly swapping with Beckett, each for 13 weeks at a time. 

On Instagram, he said: ‘The reason I’m leaving, because everybody’s asked me this, is because I wasn’t really happy with the 13 weeks on, 13 weeks off business.

‘So I did the honourable thing, I honoured my contract, gave my notice in and now I’m off.

‘Thanks very much and good luck to everyone on Radio 2 and long may it continue.’

… AND THEIR REPLACEMENTS?

SCOTT MILLS

Scott Mills is stepping down from his R1 weekday afternoon slot in order to succeed radio legend Steve Wright as the host of his programme.

It comes after the broadcaster said goodbye to Radio 1 breakfast host Nick Grimshaw and Future Sounds star Annie Mac last year. 

MICHELLE VISAGE

Michelle Visage hosts a permanent Friday night slot from 7-9pm on Radio 2 

Michelle Visage hosts a permanent Friday night slot from 7-9pm on Radio 2.

The Drag Race judge, who stepped into the limelight in the late 1980s in the States as a member of the girl band Seduction, endeared herself to the wider public in the 2010s as a judge on RuPaul’s Drag Race.

But after crossing the pond to the UK in 2019, Visage, who’s joked that she was ‘a gay British man’ in a former life, found a new fan base, taking part in Channel 5’s Celebrity Big Brother UK and remaining in the house for 30 days.

Four years later, she became an instant favourite when she strutted down the Strictly stage with Giovanni Pernice in 2019.

ANGELA GRIFFIN

Waterloo Road actress Angela Griffin hosts Radio 2 Unwinds 

Waterloo Road actress Angela Griffin hosts Radio 2 Unwinds, a Sunday night show (10pm-midnight) to take listeners on a ‘mood-boosting musical journey across genres and decades, to help them relax and switch off’.

She said: ‘I’m over the moon to be given my very own BBC Radio 2 programme. I loved presenting my series last year as I was already a huge fan of the station, so I’m proud to be given my first proper weekly show.

‘I’ll be bringing two hours of chilled out tunes curated by myself and the listeners, to help unwind and relax before the week ahead.’

DJ SPOONY

DJ Spoony hosts a Friday night slot from 9-11pm on Radio 2 

DJ Spoony hosts a Friday night slot from 9-11pm on Radio 2.

The BBC website describes the show as: ‘Non-stop two happy hour of joyful floor fillers, soulful house and lyrical garage tunes to make you feel good!’

WHO ELSE HAS RECENTLY LEFT THE BBC AND RADIO 2? 

ANDREW MARR

Andrew Marr quit the Corporation last winter to front shows on LBC and Classic FM 

Andrew Marr quit the Corporation last winter to front shows on LBC and Classic FM, and is thought to have significantly increased his pay of up to £339,999 in the move.

Marr’s new weekday show will see him become the newest member of LBC’s line-up, which includes Nick Ferrari, James O’Brien, Eddie Mair, Shelagh Fogarty, Iain Dale, Tom Swarbrick, David Lammy, Camilla Tominey and Matt Frei.

EMILY MAITLIS and JON SOPEL

Emily Maitlis and Jon Sopel followed Andrew Marr and jumped ship for LBC in February 

Emily Maitlis and Jon Sopel followed Andrew Marr and jumped ship for LBC in February this year.

The veteran journalists caused disarray at Broadcasting House after deciding to join Leicester Square-based Global, which is also home to Nick Ferrari, Eddie Mair, Shelagh Fogarty and James O’Brien.

Maitlis, who hosted Newsnight, has had a series of impartiality complaints against her because of her tweets and on-air comments about the pandemic, the Tory Government and Boris Johnson’s former chief aide Dominic Cummings.

DAN WALKER

Dan Walker also jumped ship and ditched the BBC, joining Channel 5 to be lead anchor on its revamped 5News team 

Dan Walker also jumped ship and ditched the BBC, joining Channel 5 to be lead anchor on its revamped 5News team.

He walked away from his £295,000-295,999 a year role at the Beeb

The BBC dismissed the ‘brain drain’ of top talent ditching the broadcaster as ‘people come, people go’.

GRAHAM NORTON

Graham Norton quit Radio 2 before Christmas 2020

Graham Norton quit Radio 2 before Christmas 2020, but his hugely popular talk show is still broadcast on BBC television.

He said in a statement at the time: ‘Obviously I’m sad to be stepping away from my Radio 2 show. I’ll miss being a part of the Wogan House family, as well as the listeners and their lives.’

SIMON MAYO

Simon Mayo left BBC Radio 2 for Scala Radio in 2019 

Simon Mayo left BBC Radio 2 for Scala Radio in 2019.

In May this year, he branded the broadcaster ‘soul destroying’ for the ‘hoops’ it makes people jump through to get a show greenlit – adding that his podcast fronted by two men would have ‘no chance’ in today’s woke era.

Advertisement
Comments (0)
Add Comment