Labour spin doctors have been famous for their sheer bloody nerve since the days when they jumped to the barked commands of the terrifying propagandist Alastair Campbell.
But I have never seen anything to beat the dizzying spin applied to the rusty, barnacled and long-delayed return home of the clapped-out Trident submarine HMS Vengeance on Sunday.
Vengeance made it into Faslane after a record seven months (217 days) under the waves. Downing Street, determined to present this worrying event as a triumph of British grit, decided to make a sort of celebration of the dismal news.
Defence Secretary Wes Streeting, attended by various bits of top brass, went up to Scotland to greet the boat and its crew. Reporters were invited to witness the absurdly delayed return. Families of the ship’s company lined the shore to welcome their loved ones back.
Yet this was not a record anyone wants to break or boast about. Like record NHS waiting lists, record levels of borrowing and record inflation or unemployment, it is the sort of bad news No 10 would normally want to bury.
America’s equivalent boats seldom spend more than two months submerged and, once, we kept to the same rule. But now we cannot. We have too few submarines and they are too worn-out.
Defence Secretary Wes Streeting, attended by various bits of top brass, went up to Scotland to greet the boat and its crew. Reporters were invited to witness the absurdly delayed return
The first of four vastly expensive new boats might possibly be ready by 2032, six years away, but possibly not. In the meantime, do you think this is going to get better?
This is bad news in three grim dimensions. It reveals that our nuclear deterrent is tottering with age.
Mr Streeting made a defiant speech denouncing Vladimir Putin for demanding that Britain stop protecting Europe with its deterrent, as part of any Ukraine peace deal.
This is obviously an outrageous attempt to split Nato, and Mr Streeting tried to thunder in response. He said majestically that the UK’s commitment to defending its allies with nuclear force was ‘unwavering’ and ‘unshakeable’ and that ‘the fact that Putin has made these demands demonstrates what the nuclear deterrent is, and the deterrence effect it is having in the Kremlin’.
Adding for good measure: ‘At a dangerous time for our continent, our nuclear deterrent is not up for negotiation, and we will not abandon our allies in Nato.’
Well, yes. But this would have been a bit more convincing if the backdrop had not been a weary old boat and an overworked crew.
HMS Vengeance was launched in 1998, before some of the current crop of Labour MPs were even born.
The men and women who take her to sea are being placed under near-intolerable strain, making it harder than ever to recruit and retain new submariners. Modern families are less understanding about such things than they were in the lost days of ‘mustn’t grumble’ and the stiff upper-lip.
Such long periods at sea in a submarine are a very serious business. I once spent a few days submerged in the Polaris sub HMS Repulse, one of Vengeance’s smaller fore-runners, and I learned a little about it from her (in those days all-male) crew. I suspect the arrival of women in Trident submarines has increased the tension of long patrols.
Vengeance’s 140 highly trained submariners had not seen the sun or the sky or the stars since the spring. They had been more or less totally cut off from home.
Nuclear missile submarines can receive signals, but they cannot transmit them in case they give their location away to the enemy.
If they get bad news from home, there is nothing they can do about it until they return to port, so many prefer not to be told if it arrives – a horrible choice to have to make.
Vengeance’s 140 highly trained submariners had not seen the sun or the sky or the stars since the spring. They had been more or less totally cut off from home. Wes Streeting spoke with the crew at HM Naval Base Clyde
The air they breathed had been inhaled before many times, filtered and recirculated until it was as flat and tasteless as distilled water.
Even in the days of two-month patrols, some crew members would be physically sick when they got to home port and real, fresh air flooded into their lungs.
Their eyes had grown used to the grey artificial twilight of life on board, and all of them will have been advised not to drive until those eyes have grown used to long distances again.
They will all infuriate their families for days by trying to creep about noiselessly at home, when there is no need to.
Heaven knows what they have been eating, as the boats simply do not have enough storage space for seven months’ supply of decent food.
Even washing can be difficult, as the sound of showers might give the boat’s position away to the immensely sensitive sonars which all advanced navies now possess.
For some time now, these ancient boats have been slipping quietly home to the naval base at Faslane on the Clyde, after spending far too long at sea. This is not something the Navy normally likes to admit, let alone trumpet.
Generally, the information slips out thanks to vigilant photographers on the banks of the Clyde, spotting the rust-streaked subs as they crawl back to base, and also unofficial maritime websites, which keep an eye on such things. Though you may be very sure the details are known in Moscow too, and have been for years.
It is getting very bad. Six of the previous seven patrols lasted 200 days, and the last nine all exceeded five months.
This is the first to break seven months, and the reason for Vengeance’s extra-late homecoming is dismal. Her even older sister ship, HMS Vanguard (launched in 1992), was supposed to replace her. But, ridiculously, she had to scamper back to base for spare parts.
The epidemic of conking out and breakdowns, which has afflicted the rest of the Royal Navy for years now, has definitely taken hold in the deterrent fleet.
Are they even still secure? How can we be certain? Our enemies will not let us know if they have managed to detect them.
HMS Vengeance was launched in 1998, before some of the current crop of Labour MPs were even born
I agree with that great Labour Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin, who said in 1946 that this country must have its own nuclear bomb. He said: ‘We’ve got to have this thing over here whatever it costs… We’ve got to have the bloody Union Jack on top of it.’
Rather ironically, he felt this way because he had been snubbed quite badly by the Americans, so the origin of our deterrent lies in resentment of Washington more than in fear of Moscow. Even so, after all it has cost us, it would be crazy to get rid of it.
Yet a lot of people just can’t grasp that there is more than one way of having a nuclear deterrent. Israel, for instance, deters its neighbours with a much more compact force.
Since 1969, Britain has sought to maintain a superpower Cold War missile system, a mini version of America’s. And in trying to do so, we have become more dependent on the US, which leases us the missiles, and less and less able to afford or maintain the hardware.
This is why our conventional forces are so squeezed and small.
Might this not in fact be the moment to switch to something more modest than Trident, which we can afford, and which will still allow us to hold up our heads as a significant power?