Supermarket tomato soup costing simply 59p named finest in UK — higher than Heinz and Baxters

The 59p tomato soup beat leading brands in a taste test.

Supermarket tomato soup costing just 59p has beated Heinz and Baxters in a taste test(Image: Getty)

For countless shoppers, price signals quality – the pricier something is, the superior it must be. However, that’s not always true, particularly when pitting supermarket own-label food and drink against pricier branded alternatives. Take, for instance, a supermarket coffee that recently triumphed over Kenco and Nescafé in a taste trial.

And a supermarket tomato soup has been named the finest in Britain, beating household favourites like Heinz and Baxters, reports Wales Online. At merely 59p per tin, it costs a third of what market leader Heinz charges. Strikingly, the priciest tin of tomato soup tested finished bottom in the rankings.

Which? – recognised as a premier UK consumer champion – gathered a panel of 77 soup lovers to sample 12 tinned tomato soups. Here’s their verdict:

Article continues below

Baxters Cream of Tomato Soup – 58%: The priciest soup tested scored lowest overall. Most tasters deemed the flavour too weak, while the texture lacked sufficient thickness. £2.05 for 400g (51p per 100g).

Baxters Cream of Tomato Soup and Waitrose Essential Cream of Tomato Soup were the lowest-scoring tins on the list(Image: Google)

Waitrose Essential Cream of Tomato Soup – 66%: Waitrose registered the poorest score among own-label soups. Which? noted “it lost marks for flavour, and around half thought it wasn’t thick or creamy enough”. 85p for 400g (21p per 100g).

Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup – 68%: Heavyweight Heinz placed near the bottom of the table. Which? reported “more than a third thought the flavour was too weak and not sweet enough, while 62% said it wasn’t creamy enough”. £1.70 for 400g (43p per 100g).

Lidl Newgate Cream of Tomato Soup – 70%: Testers said Lidl’s soup “looked the part” but “the flavour and texture fell slightly short”. 59p for 400g (15p per 100g).

Aldi Bramwells Cream of Tomato Soup – 71%: Scoring marginally higher than Lidl, Aldi “impressed on appearance, but its texture wasn’t on par with top-ranking rivals, with more than half finding it lacked creaminess”. 59p for 400g (15p per 100g).

Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup finished towards the bottom of the list, while Aldi Bramwells Cream of Tomato Soup just beat Lidl’s soup

Morrisons Cream of Tomato Soup – 72%: Testers described it as “a decent option” and it performed well on colour and sweetness. However, just over a third wanted a more robust tomato flavour and additional tanginess. 65p for 400g (16p per 100g).

Marks and Spencer Cream of Tomato Soup – 73%: Which? reported its testers “particularly liked the thickness and creaminess of this tinned soup” and noted: “At 60p, it offers good value for M&S shoppers.” 60p for 400g (15p per 100g).

Co-op Classic Cream of Tomato Soup – 73%: Characterised as “a solid contender with good creaminess and well-balanced flavours”, this soup carries a slightly higher price tag than numerous own brand rivals. Testers observed that “aroma and appearance didn’t quite match up to higher-scoring tins”. 75p for 400g (19p per 100g).

Crosse and Blackwell Cream of Tomato Soup – 76%: This emerged as the highest-rated brand tested, though while cheaper than Heinz, it still costs roughly twice the price of most supermarket own labels. £1.25 for 400g (31p per 100g).

Asda Cream of Tomato Soup – 77%: Securing third place overall and awarded “Best Buy” status, Asda’s soup scored highly for appearance, aroma, flavour and texture, delivering well-balanced flavours alongside pleasing creaminess. The panel awarded it impressive marks throughout. 59p for 400g (15p per 100g).

Sainsbury’s Cream of Tomato Soup and Tesco Cream of Tomato Soup tied for top spot when it came to the best tins of tomato soup in the UK(Image: Google)

Tesco Cream of Tomato Soup – 78%: This shared top spot, with testers noting “it excelled on every measure, with just the right strength of flavour and tang for the majority of tasters”. They added: “Unlike some lower-scoring soups, there was no compromising on texture, with top marks for thickness and creaminess.” 59p for 400g (15p per 100g).

Sainsbury’s Cream of Tomato Soup – 78%: The joint highest-scoring tin, this wallet-friendly soup from Sainsbury’s wowed the testers. Which? said: “Most tasters found the balance of tanginess and sweetness just right. It also won over tasters on appearance and texture, with three quarters rating it the perfect creaminess. It also outstanding value at just 59p a tin.” 59p for 400g (15p per 100g).

Article continues below

How the top instant tomato soup was selected

Each tomato soup was evaluated on overall flavour, texture, appearance, aroma, sweetness, tanginess, thickness and creaminess. It was carried out as a blind taste test, meaning testers weren’t told whether they were trying Heinz, Baxters or a cheaper supermarket option. They were also banned from discussing their opinions to prevent swaying other testers.

foodTesco