People who are cruel to animals can be cruel to their partners as well. Just ask mum Annette Bramley, whose 26-year-old daughter Holly was murdered by her husband, Nicholas Metson.
The ruthless killer had a history of harming his wife’s pets – and every time he did, it was a warning of the horrors to come.
Now Annette wants the law changed so Brits can find out if a partner has a history of animal abuse. Here she tells Star Paws columnist Catherine Lamb about the Holly’s Law campaign…
“Holly was a beautiful, caring and gentle soul, who was coerced, controlled and isolated by a man who ultimately murdered her,” Annette Bramley says.
It’s still an emotional subject for the 67-year-old, who describes how Nicholas Metson forced her daughter to leave home and cut all ties with family and friends.
But even then, she wasn’t quite helpless enough – so he started to harm her beloved pets. He once bought Holly a puppy, then put it in a washing machine in their Lincoln home to try and kill it. When that didn’t work, he drowned the tiny creature in the bath.
It’s a devastating example of how some abusers use animals to control their victims. “When Holly threatened to leave him, he killed her too,” Annette adds.
“This is why recognising animal abuse is so important. It should never be treated as an isolated animal welfare matter when there may be a much wider safeguarding issue.”
Before Holly’s murder, in March 2023, her family knew Metson had a conviction for revenge pornography. It made them suspicious of him from the start.
But they had not been told he assaulted an ex-partner, leading to a conviction for actual bodily harm, and had a history of animal abuse spanning roughly 18 years.
Annette, from Holbeach, Lincs, explains: “He had been known to the RSPCA from the age of eight, but had never been prosecuted, having repeatedly avoided prosecution on technicalities.”
The events organiser now believes knowing more about him could have saved her daughter from a horrifying death.
Metson stabbed Holly at least four times, then cut her body into 224 pieces and stored it in the larder of their flat. He later paid a friend £50 to help him dump the remains in a river.
“Holly cannot be brought back, but her story can help prevent others experiencing the same fate,” Annette says. “Ultimately, this is about preventing domestic abuse, protecting animals and, hopefully, saving lives.”
The Holly’s Law campaign is now calling for a “proportionate disclosure scheme,” so people can check whether potential partners have a history of animal abuse. Activists also want police trained on the link to domestic violence, so they can identify situations where pets are being used to control victims.
Mark Randall, of Naturewatch Foundation, says: “For too long, animal cruelty has been viewed primarily through an animal welfare lens. We are establishing that it is also a public protection and safeguarding issue.”
The retired detective is leading the charity’s Protect Animals. Protect People campaign, which has won the support of 113 MPs. He says 30 years in policing taught him to pay attention to behaviours, connections and patterns.
“Animal abuse and violence against people are often part of the same picture,” he adds. That makes information about crimes against animals an important part of any risk assessment of a new partner.
“It is not about labelling someone an abuser because of an allegation, nor about creating a blanket register,” Mark explains. “It is about making sure relevant information reaches those making safeguarding decisions, so warning signs are not overlooked.”
The campaign took a major step forward last week, when Sir John Hayes MP led a parliamentary adjournment debate on animal cruelty and domestic abuse. Annette hopes it will encourage the Government to take further action.
“I don’t want us to be having this conversation after another tragedy,” says Mark. “I want us to use what we already know to identify the risks earlier and prevent harm.”
Spotting the signs of coercive control
In a person, remember ABC…
A – Appearance: Changes in how a person looks can signal stress or fear.
B – Behaviour: Sudden changes in mood or habits can indicate underlying abuse.
C – Conversation: Listen to what is being said – and what isn’t.
Then check in on the family pet:
- Do they show physical signs of abuse, such as limping?
- Are there behavioural changes, like, sudden aggression?
- Is their tail tucked? Do they flinch at human contact or urinate when approached?