London24NEWS

Man who stopped at facet of highway to assist choking spouse fined £105

When he got a £70 fine and explained to the council the emergency, they increased the charge to £105

James Brice, 69, pulled over when his wife was choking and received a fine

James Brice, 69, pulled over when his wife was choking and received a fine

A man who stopped at the side of the road to help his choking wife has been hit with a £105 fine. James Brice, 69, said the local authority has repeatedly ignored his appeal explaining that he had only pulled in to deal with a medical emergency.

The incident happened outside Rochester station in Kent, part of Medway Council’s red route scheme, on August 2. Mr Brice, who believes he stopped for a maximum of four minutes, received a £70 penalty notice just three days later, reduced to £35 if paid within two weeks.

“It was just after six in the morning; there were no other cars around, I wasn’t blocking anyone,” he said. “I wasn’t picking anyone up, and no-one got out – what did they think was my reason for stopping? Anyone would have done what I did in a medical emergency. Three hundred people a year die from choking; I’m going to help my wife. I was there for three or four minutes, that’s all.

Article continues below
Medway Council introduced red routes in May 2024

Medway Council introduced red routes in May 2024

“When I got the fine, I thought ‘Oh well, never mind, I’ll just explain what happened’ and they would understand.”

Mr Brice, from Strood, tried to appeal the decision on the authority’s website without success so resorted to posting a letter to explain what had happened. He heard nothing back and instead, at the end of August, a second penalty notice arrived raising the fine to £105.

Getting increasingly frustrated, he resorted to hand-delivering a letter to Medway Council’s headquarters in Chatham. But he still had not received a reply by the deadline of November 5 and fearing prosecution, paid the charge.

Mr Brice said he felt scammed and could not understand why Medway Council were so fast to issue a fine but did not respond to his attempts to appeal it. That’s the really annoying thing. It just feels like they want to scam anyone, just to get our money. As far as I’m concerned, they have not done their jobs,” he said.

An ANPR camera (Automatic Number Plate Recognition)

An ANPR camera (Automatic Number Plate Recognition)

“I’ve been driving for fifty years, when I’ve had a speeding fine or a parking fine, I’ve paid it. If they had replied to me saying ‘We understand why, but it’s not enough of a reason,’I would have accepted it and paid the £35 – but they took so long now it’s become £105.

“They didn’t respond for days, and then when they did, it was only to tell me I owed them more money. I paid it just to get it over with, and I wonder how many people don’t bother to fight it and just pay up. I wonder how they would feel if my wife had died and then I’d received the fine.”

The council rescinded the fine when contacted by media but gave Mr Brice no explanation. Medway introduced the red route scheme which bans drivers from stopping in restricted areas to keep traffic flowing in May 2024.

Article continues below

The system is enforced by automatic number plate recognition (ANPR) cameras, and those who break the rules are hit with a £70 fine. A Medway Council spokesperson said it received James’ first letter on August 11 but rejected his appeal due to “lack of evidence and activity seen around the vehicle” and sent him a letter on August 26.

This would have been 21 days after the original fine was sent, meaning the cost had already risen to £70. However, the authority said there was a wording issue within the notice of rejection which meant it had now cancelled the fine.