Alan Milburn warns blueprint to sort out Neets disaster will not be ‘pain-free’ with some to lose help
In his long-awaited report – spanning over 270 pages – the ex-Labour Cabinet minister Alan Milburn proposed a controversial welfare state shake-up for under-25s
Alan Milburn has warned his blueprint to tackle Britain’s ‘Neets’ crisis will not be “pain-free” with some young people set to lose financial support.
In his long-awaited report – spanning over 270 pages – the ex-Labour Cabinet minister proposed a controversial welfare state shake-up for under-25s. It is combined with a multi-billion pound boost in support schemes to help the almost one million young people between the ages of 16 and 24 back into employment, education, or training.
Mr Milburn, who addressed Andy Burnham’s Cabinet on Tuesday with his findings, recommends an initial £500million cash injection in the 2027 spending review. By 2036-2037 he said this should rise to a £5.8billion annual boost to help over 440,000 youngsters back into work.
His 10-year plan to radically reduce the UK’s ‘Neet’ rate includes a first of its kind legal guarantee for young people to offer work or training and a duty on government to deliver. His proposal will be made possible by annual welfare savings of £3.6billion and £2.4billion in extra tax revenues from people in work.
But among the most contentious and politically thorny proposals, Mr Milburn proposes an entirely new and different benefits system for under-25s.
To see more of the stories you love from The Mirror and to find them easily in Google then make us your preferred source. Free and easy-to-do, just click on the link here to find more from The Mirror at the top of your feed.
His report argues the “best reform option is one that has never been tried before – the creation of a new and different system for young people from the one that serves older adults”.
It involves a new “youth allowance” replacing the health element of Universal Credit (UC) and the personal independence payment (PIP) for 16 to 24-year-olds. Under the new system, the report says those with conditions such as anxiety, ADHD and autism “would be both expected and enabled to work”.
But there will be a new and more financially generous “severe and complex needs” insurance scheme for the minority of young people where it is clear they will likely never be able to work, the report states.
His report – published on Tuesday – is frank, adding: “These changes will not be easy to make. Nor will they be pain-free. They could mean some people get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system.
“But the approach I have taken is to try to define what would give young people the best chance of building a good life, not just over a year or two but over the course of their lifetimes.”
Launching his report at a press conference at Google’s offices in central London, Mr Milburn said: “Britain is at risk of losing a generation of young people, not because they lack talent, not because they lack ambition, not because they do not want to work. This is not a crisis of aspiration, it is a crisis of opportunity.”
He said “half measures will not do” because “the scale of the problem is just too big for that”.
“We have reached a profound moment of choice for the country, it calls for a new approach to back the next generation, to make young people a top priority. This is not what we have been doing.”
Mr Burnham described the publication of the report as a “watershed moment”.
He said: “I said to the cabinet this morning, I don’t think a British Cabinet has sat around that table in 50 years or more and talked about a vision for young people, support from the very early years all the way through school and then into opportunity beyond school.”
But pressed on whether he was going to cut benefits for young people, the Prime Minister told Sky News: “I don’t want anybody to lose out here. This is not about punishing anybody. It’s about saving money because young people are moving from education, training and into work and there’s no need for anybody to miss out.
He insisted he would make the argument for reform with Labour backbenchers, telling Sky News: “Things are tough if you make changes on this scale. But I’m saying to you today, I’ve been in politics a long time. I have never in my years in politics seen a wholesale, whole government approach to supporting the next generation.
“That is what this represents, and I am absolutely confident that I can take this vision and get people behind it, indeed get the country behind it, because we will not place Britain in the position I want it to be in. If we have a generation of young people growing up without hope for the future.”
Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told MPs that Mr Burnham’s Cabinet has endorsed the need for a whole new settlement for young people. MPs will get a vote on government plans next year, with a white paper due to be published once ministers have considered the whole report.
It will be combined with a response to the upcoming Timms review on the main disability – Personal Independence Payments (PIP). The DWP minister Sir Stephen Timms was tasked with the review after Keir Starmer was forced to abandon his botched welfare reforms in 2025. Mr McFadden said the government rejects attempts to label young people as “snowflakes and shirkers”.
He said: “We reject that entirely. The fault does not lay with the young people themselves. They want to work. They want to learn. It is for us to make sure that they have a chance to do so.
“So our message to young people, the message from me, from the Prime Minister, from the whole cabinet, is that we value you, we believe in you, and we want you to have a future.”
The government proposals set the stage for one of the first major tests of Mr Burnham’s premiership. Some left-wing MPs have already expressed concern, including Jeremy Corbyn’s former Shadow Chancellor, John McDonnell.
He said: “The receipt of Pip and universal credit health elements keeps 120,000 young people out of poverty. So the question does remain: why is it that young people, if benefit cuts go ahead, are forced to pay for the new system and we’re not taxing wealth?”
Mr McFadden responded in the Commons: “We are putting forward this new settlement because we believe it is a better deal for young people Let’s get the support to the young people so that they have the experience of earning, of making their way, and that’s what this settlement offers.”
But some of the key rebels involved in the 2025 welfare rebellion now serve in Mr Burnham’s Cabinet, including Louise Haigh, who is now the Prime Minister’s second-in-command.
Labour MP Dr Marie Tidball, who was close to tears during last year’s rebellion in a powerful Commons intervention, said she welcomed the “significant shift in the government’s approach to welfare and employment support and the reforms set out in the Milburn review”.
She added: “I am pleased there won’t be crude cuts to benefits.” Dr Tidball also vowed to continue speaking for disabled people’s organisations “as I have done since I was elected”.
Appearing on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Mr Milburn also insisted the package of proposals was not about “crude cuts” to the benefits bill.
Pressed on whether some young people might get more help from the state into work while losing a lot of money, he responded: “Overall, you’re absolutely right, the benefits bill will fall.
“And the amount of money we’re putting into employment support will rise to enable more young people into work. At the moment for every £25 we’re spending on income support, on benefits for young people, we’re only spending £1 on employment support.”
He added: “Some people – I don’t deny this – some people will be worse off, initially. At the same time we’re putting in more money in kind, in support, in services, in opportunities, to enable young people to do what they want to do, which is to get a job.”
The Resolution Foundation’s Ruth Curtice said the report rose to the challenge the country faces in providing enough education, employment, and training opportunities for young people.
But she added: “The proposed welfare reforms are likely to be the most contested aspect of this review even though they’ll play a relatively small role in tackling Britain’s NEET crisis.
“The biggest winners may well be those already in work, while those with health conditions who struggle to work could lose out.
“The move away from a ‘left alone’ approach to welfare is welcome, though the overall benefit savings of £3.6 billion by 2036-37 that Milburn says his programme would achieve suggest that some young people – likely those whose health or disability prevents them from working – could be considerably worse off.”
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has previously estimated young people could lose out on about £50 a week if they are no longer entitled to claim the health element of Universal Credit (UC),
And they could lose between £30 and £195 a week if they are also barred from the PIP disability benefit (Personal Independence Payment).
James Taylor, executive director of strategy at the disability equality charity, Scope, welcomed the “ambition to transform employment support for young people” but said they are “deeply concerned by proposals that could leave some young disabled people with less financial support”.
He added: “PIP helps with the extra costs of disability, whether someone is in work or not. Taking that support away could make it harder, not easier, for young disabled people to get into work and live independently.
“The Government must be ambitious about creating jobs and opportunities for young disabled people. But that ambition must not come at the cost of the vital financial support they need.”
George Bangham from the New Economics Foundation said: “There’s much to welcome in Alan Milburn’s review, including calls for more investment in employment support and a guarantee of a job, training or support for every young person. But the positives risk being overshadowed by his argument for cuts to health and disability benefits.
“There is little evidence that health benefits are too generous or that they are driving young people out of work, while cutting them is likely to push people into poverty and make it harder for them to find work.
“Cuts to benefits also don’t solve the fundamental problem that there aren’t enough opportunities for young people. Recent NEF research found that in Blackpool there are only five online vacancies for every 100 people out of work and on Universal Credit.”
