‘New youth jobs plan may rescue a ‘misplaced technology’ – at a steep value’
If there is one thing that parents are used to, it’s fighting for their children’s future. Whether it’s navigating broken and underfunded SEND systems, finding themselves stuck on endlessly long NHS waiting lists, or watching their children try to kickstart their adult lives in a crumbling economy, parents are painfully aware of the difficult situation that millions of young people are growing up in. With the rise of AI, a relentless cost-of-living crisis, and entry-level jobs harder to come by than ever, many of us genuinely fear for what lies ahead.
So, when a landmark government-commissioned report, led by former Health Secretary Alan Milburn, proposes a £5.8 billion rescue plan to guarantee young people a route into work, an apprenticeship or training, it sounds like the lifeline we have been begging for.
But as any parent knows, the devil is always in the detail. Looking closer at how much of this ‘opportunity guarantee’ relies on squeezing the benefit safety net for young adults with health conditions, it is impossible not to feel a sharp pang of anxiety about what could happen to the most vulnerable.
But what does this 10-year plan actually mean for families? Here is a breakdown of the biggest proposals – and my verdict.
Welfare
- The report proposes separating under-25s from the adult welfare system. For 18-to-24-year-olds, the Universal Credit health top-up would be scrapped in favour of a single ‘Youth Allowance’, alongside strict rules meaning those who refuse to engage with job offers face sanctions if they persistently refuse to engage or turn down reasonable offers without good cause, after attempts to re-engage them.
- Personal Independence Payment (PIP) – currently worth up to £778.40 every four weeks – would be scrapped for under-25s. It would be replaced by a targeted ‘Additional Cost Allowance’ for those with significant, ongoing disability costs, a more generous ‘Severe and Complex Needs Insurance’ for those with the most profound disabilities who will never be able to work, and a local flexible disability fund for others. It is thought some of the 453,000 who currently claim it would no longer be eligible, with a tightening on eligibility.
- Child Disability Living Allowance (DLA) would be extended from age 16 to 18.
Verdict: Let’s start on a high: extending child DLA is a victory for common sense. At 16, most children are still in education, still growing up and heavily reliant on family support. Forcing them into the adult benefit system at this age can cause a lot of unnecessary stress – so this two-year extension would give them some much-needed breathing space during an already stressful time.
Around 77 per cent of Child DLA claimants transition directly onto Personal Independence Payment (PIP) by age 17, prompting this proposed overhaul – which is going to cause huge alarm.
Moving away from a guaranteed monthly payment for many young adults to a system where young adults would have to apply to a fund for specific one-off costs could be seen as stripping away their independence.
The report argues that the existing system traps young people by continuously documenting what they cannot do rather than asking what they could do with proper support, which sets young people on an early path towards economic inactivity.
But, threatening unwell, stressed young people with losing their Youth Allowance if they don’t comply isn’t a magic wand for productivity – for many, it will trigger panic.
Education
- The review makes it clear that prevention has to start early on – with primary and secondary schools identifying pupils at risk of becoming Neet.
- Key proposals include raising the national ambition so that by 2036, at least 90% of children are school-ready at age five – which includes basic independence like being out of nappies.
- Drawing on the legacy of Sure Start, it calls for expanding Family Hubs into a national programme – especially in disadvantaged areas
- There would be a new writing, numeracy and oracy check around Year 8 – this wouldn’t be an exam, but a check on how students are performing, and schools would have more timetable flexibility to tailor learning to pupil strengths
- Schools would be required to offer work experience
- Aim to double the number of young people completing apprenticeships
- New vocational GCSES from age 14, and lightening the examination burden which sees pupils sit all their exams in an intense six-week period
- Phone free school days and social media curbs for under-16s
Verdict: Finally an end to the work experience racket that many of us have witnessed. Far too many placements are being arranged through family connections. Making work experience a statutory duty for school’s would help level the playing field.
Many parents have watched their children buckle under the pressure-cooker environment that the current curriculum demands, with lots of young people ending up trapped in a cycle where they are required to resit GCSE English and maths after failing.
And lots of people will be cheering at the push for more vocational routes, and any attempts to improve the examination burden – it seems unbearably unfair that you have to sit all the exams that determine your future over just a few weeks.
But most schools are operating at breaking point, and many will be anxious to understand how they can access the funding needed to back up these proposals.
Autism, ADHD and mental health
- With sky-high waiting lists for youth mental health assessments, Milburn has warned that poor health “should not become a one-way route out of education and work”.
- Rather than getting stuck in a bottleneck as they await a formal diagnosis, the report says NEETS should have guaranteed access to fast-track services like talking therapies and counselling within three months, even without a diagnosis.
- Milburn has criticised a “cash for diagnosis” approach from some private providers who carry out ADHD and autism assessments, and said some young people are being failed when they get a diagnosis “when they should not get one”.
Verdict: Any parent who has spent years languishing on a Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) waiting list can attest that the system is broken. Dropping the requirement to have a formal diagnosis before a child can receive support could be transformative.
That a key reason young people are unemployed is poor mental health only makes it more obvious that the stress of losing their benefits will hardly make them feel more equipped to seek or stay in work.
Overview: There is a lot of hope in this blueprint – which is sorely needed for this generation. As the head of an independent review into mental health, ADHD and autism said earlier this year, it is harder to be young.
But whether this becomes a genuine turning point for our children – as I sorely hope it will – or just another broken Westminster promise, depends entirely on one thing: the government must put the funding, the jobs, and the mental health support securely in place before they even think about cutting the safety net.
The Prime Minister has said the report should be a “watershed moment” but the Government did not immediately commit to implementing all the changes demanded by Mr Milburn, which would cost up to £5.8 billion annually.
